Zum Inhalt springen

English:Peace, conflict and just war reasoning - Ethics Year 9

Aus MOOCsWiki Staging
aiMOOC-Siegel aiMOOC

Peace, conflict and just war reasoning - Ethics Year 9

QR-Code



Introduction

Compare principled pacifism with just war reasoning. Evaluate a fictional public decision using evidence, civilian protection and opportunities for peace.


Recognise two approaches to conflict

Principled pacifism opposes participating in war as a matter of moral conviction. Pacifists may support active alternatives such as mediation, help for people displaced by conflict or nonviolent resistance. There are different pacifist traditions and arguments. The Quaker peace testimony is one example. It combines an objection to bearing arms with work towards peace and practical relief for people affected by war.

Just war reasoning asks whether any use of force could be morally justified under demanding conditions. Thomas Aquinas’s historical account looks at authority, cause and intention. Later forms of reasoning also ask hard questions about alternatives, likely consequences and civilian protection. An account of what a particular thinker or religious group teaches cannot stand for every person in a religion, country or community.

The Peace Palace behind iron fencing, with red brick walls, a tall tower and gardens.
The Peace Palace in The Hague houses the International Court of Justice. It illustrates that some disputes can be addressed through legal institutions as well as through mediation.


Test reasons before reaching a judgement

Just cause asks what serious wrong a proposed response addresses. Protecting people from a verified attack can be offered as a reason in this tradition. Revenge and gaining prestige are different purposes. Legitimate authority asks who has responsibility for making the decision and whether it is subject to accountable procedures. Right intention asks whether the aim is protection and a just peace.

Last resort asks whether realistic, less harmful ways of protecting people have been seriously considered. Proportionality in this moral discussion weighs the expected harms against the good the response could achieve. Reasonable prospects asks what evidence suggests the approach could achieve its stated protective purpose. A serious cause alone cannot answer questions about authority, alternatives or likely harm.

Another question concerns how people would be treated during a conflict. International humanitarian law has its own legal rules for protecting civilians and others who are not, or are no longer, taking part in the fighting. The ICRC film introduces those humanitarian protections. The written sections explain the distinction between judging a decision to use force and judging conduct during an armed conflict.


Evaluate a proposal in two fictional states

Fictional case. A border incident has forced residents of two neighbouring states to leave home. Two independent reports confirm displacement. The local accounts do not yet establish who initiated the incident. Officials in one state ask for a broadly worded authorisation to use force. A regional mediator offers independent verification and talks to keep essential aid moving. Some displaced families have not been consulted.

A worked judgement. The harm gives reason to protect people. Missing evidence about how the incident began weakens claims about what response can be justified. An accountable public decision requires clarity about who can authorise the proposal and for what purpose. The mediator’s offer is a real possibility to investigate under last resort. With an undefined scope and uncertain protective benefit, proportionality and reasonable prospects are hard to demonstrate. The available facts support prioritising aid, verification and mediation while reviewing how conditions change.

A principled pacifist can endorse those actions and reject war on moral grounds. A believer in just war reasoning could also reject the current proposal and argue that verified facts could alter part of the assessment. Both can agree on protecting displaced civilians. Their reasons and their possible future conclusions differ.

A black circle containing a vertical line and two diagonals branching down.
Gerald Holtom designed this symbol in 1958 for the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament. It later became widely associated with peace. The two perspectives can share a goal while offering distinct arguments.


Protect civilians and think past a ceasefire

Civilians must be protected under the applicable rules of international humanitarian law. The obligation to respect these rules applies regardless of a party’s view about why it is fighting. The ICRC’s introduction discusses protection of civilians and care for the wounded. The written alternative is to explain these two protections and why they remain relevant even if a party claims a just cause.

Stopping violence is one part of peace. People may still need safe access to services, support for return or resettlement, and a fair process for addressing grievances. Reconciliation aims to rebuild the ability to live together. Listening to harmed people and taking responsibility can support it. Forgiveness is a personal decision and cannot be demanded as the price of receiving help.


Transfer the reasoning to a proposed ceasefire extension

New fictional case. An existing ceasefire has reduced harm in two towns. A mediator proposes extending it and including residents from both towns in a discussion about repairs and services. Some people fear the agreement will leave earlier harms unaddressed. Independent observers are available, but the parties have not agreed how complaints would be heard.

Identify facts, uncertainty and voices that need to be included. Compare two civilian protections and explain how an extension plus a fair complaints process might address the competing concerns. Consider a principled pacifist argument for maintaining the ceasefire and a just war assessment of alternatives, likely outcomes and proportionality. What information would strengthen or change each judgement?

Aim for eight of ten quick checks. In a written judgement use at least four criteria, acknowledge a counterargument and recommend a step that protects civilians and supports peace.


Interactive Tasks


Quiz: Test Your Knowledge

Which response is consistent with principled pacifism in the example? (Reject war as a matter of conviction while supporting mediation and civilian relief.) (!Treat war as acceptable whenever it is popular.) (!Assume doing nothing is the only possible response.) (!Decide that refugees should wait until a dispute is settled.)



What does a just cause question ask? (What serious wrong would the proposed response address?) (!Which venue is most suitable for a press conference?) (!Which party would receive the most public praise?) (!Whether a reason has been repeated more than once.)



Which feature concerns legitimate authority? (The decision is taken by accountable people with responsibility for it.) (!A loud supporter claims an outcome is certain.) (!A proposal is more expensive than its alternatives.) (!The most dramatic statement is made first.)



How does the mediator’s offer affect last-resort reasoning? (It provides a realistic less harmful option to consider seriously.) (!It proves that every fact is already known.) (!It removes the relevance of civilian protection.) (!It settles the moral question for all circumstances.)



What does moral proportionality compare in this lesson? (Expected harms and the good the proposed response could achieve.) (!The physical size of the two states.) (!Prices of identical materials in both towns.) (!Number of speeches given by each official.)



What can the reports establish on their own? (People were displaced, but the reports do not establish who initiated the incident.) (!Each resident agrees about who began the incident.) (!The proposal will reliably achieve a just peace.) (!No one outside the two governments has relevant information.)



What remains true in conflict regardless of a party’s view of its cause? (The applicable humanitarian rules protecting civilians still matter.) (!A claim of just cause excuses all conduct.) (!The most persuasive speech decides who is protected.) (!Civilian protection is relevant only in peacetime.)



Which step helps address the concerns about extending the ceasefire? (Include affected residents and agree a fair way to hear grievances.) (!Treat reduced violence as proof no one has a grievance.) (!Demand that everyone forgive before helping with repairs.) (!Ignore the people in one town to speed up the process.)



How can the two ethical approaches support the same immediate decision? (Both can support mediation and civilian relief while giving different reasons.) (!They must agree on every judgement whenever their first action matches.) (!Only people who reject all moral principles can support talks.) (!Neither can assess a peaceful alternative.)



What would make a final judgement stronger? (Name the criteria and uncertainty, then address a plausible counterargument.) (!Repeat the conclusion without mentioning any relevant facts.) (!Attribute an official’s action to an entire religion.) (!Treat a symbol as evidence that every argument made for peace is sound.)





Memory Game

pacifism a family of positions opposing war or violence
authority responsible power to make an accountable decision
proportionality here, weighing expected harms against the good sought
mediation assistance from a third party to seek an agreement
ceasefire an agreement or arrangement to stop fighting
reconciliation work to rebuild relationships after conflict





Drag and Drop

Ask what serious harm motivates the proposal Test just cause
Ask who can authorise it Test legitimate authority
Assess a credible mediation offer Test last resort
Weigh likely harms against expected protection Test moral proportionality
Hear victims and address grievances Work towards reconciliation





Crossword Puzzle

Pacifism A family of positions opposing war or violence
Authority Responsible power to make a decision
Proportionality In this moral discussion, weighing harms against expected good
Mediation Help from a third party to seek agreement
Ceasefire An arrangement stopping the fighting
Reconciliation Rebuilding relationships after conflict





LearningApps

Optional extra practice. Choose an appropriate activity with your teacher. If the external collection is unavailable, use the native activities and independent tasks in this course.


Cloze Text

Complete the explanation.
A family of positions opposing war or violence is

. The responsible power to make a decision is

. Weighing expected harms and benefits is a question of moral

. A third party may assist in

. An arrangement to stop fighting is a

. Rebuilding relationships after harm is part of

.



Open Tasks


Easy

  1. Name an active peace response: Give an example of practical action consistent with principled pacifism.
  2. Distinguish facts and claims: Say what the independent reports establish and what remains uncertain.
  3. Define just cause: State the difference between seeking protection and seeking revenge.
  4. Identify a voice to hear: Name one group not yet adequately represented in the first example.


Standard

  1. Consider last resort: Explain why the mediator’s offer is relevant to the current proposal.
  2. Apply proportionality: Explain why uncertain benefits and unclear scope matter to the judgement.
  3. Distinguish law and moral debate: Use the text or film to explain why civilians are still protected when a party believes its cause is just.
  4. Compare arguments: Explain how a pacifist and a supporter of just war reasoning could reach the same immediate recommendation.


Advanced

  1. Evaluate at least four criteria: Assess the first proposal using four criteria, one uncertainty and a plausible counterargument.
  2. Plan for reconciliation: Propose one way to address grievances while continuing to provide assistance.
  3. Compare the ceasefire options: Apply alternatives, proportionality and reasonable prospects to the new case.
  4. Assess new evidence: Say what evidence would change one part of a judgement without assuming facts about either population.



Learning Check

  1. Compare the two positions: How might the pacifist and just war approaches view the current proposal?
  2. Apply at least four tests: Give a judgement on the authorisation using four criteria.
  3. Explain a legal protection: Why do rules protecting civilians apply even if a party regards its cause as just?
  4. Evaluate a counterargument: How can you address the worry that mediation may be too slow?
  5. Connect justice and peace: What could address harm after a ceasefire without requiring forgiveness?
  6. Transfer to a ceasefire extension: Recommend an option in the second case and identify what is uncertain.


Worked checks and assessment guidance

  1. A principled pacifist rejects war and can actively support aid and mediation. A just war analysis can reject this proposal because the facts, alternatives and likely benefits are insufficiently established while allowing that another case could receive a different evaluation.
  2. Protection is a possible just cause but the triggering facts remain uncertain. Authority and purpose must be publicly accountable. The mediator’s offer matters to last resort. Proportionality and prospects are unresolved because expected harm and protective benefit are unclear. A reason to act promptly supports urgent aid and review.
  3. The applicable rules on conduct protect people during armed conflict. A party’s judgement about starting or joining that conflict does not remove those rules. Care for wounded people and protection of civilians illustrate their humanitarian purpose.
  4. Acknowledge the urgency and ask what verification, aid and protection are possible now. Compare realistic timeframes and risks. A concern about delay needs evidence and does not by itself establish that the proposed use of force would help.
  5. Keep services and support accessible, include harmed residents and create a fair way to hear and address grievances. Reconciliation can involve responsibility and repair while leaving individual decisions about forgiveness to those affected.
  6. Consider extending the ceasefire along with independent observation and an agreed complaints process. This could preserve reduced harm and address grievances. Check whether the parties will cooperate and whose access to assistance remains uncertain.


Learning evidence

Reach eight of ten quick checks. Compare the approaches and justify a decision using at least four criteria, a counterargument and one civilian protection.


OER and Wikipedia

Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, Question 40, translated by the Fathers of the English Dominican Province, gives a historical account of authority, just cause and right intention. Quaker faith and practice, chapter 24, gives the Religious Society of Friends in Britain’s peace testimony and examples of peace work.

United Nations Charter, including Article 2 on peaceful settlement and Article 51 concerning self-defence, provides a separate legal framework. International Committee of the Red Cross, What is international humanitarian law? describes protections during armed conflict. Both cases are fictional and were written for this course.

Peace Palace, The Hague by Iamthestig, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons. Displayed unchanged.

Peace symbol, design by Gerald Holtom and SVG by Crotalus horridus, Public domain, Wikimedia Commons. Displayed unchanged.

What are the Rules of War? by International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC). The course text covers civilian protection and distinguishes legal rules from moral arguments.


Linked learning areas


aiMOOC Projects



Schulfach+




aiMOOCs



aiMOOC Projekte









MOOCwiki · Deutsch

Nach dem Lernen ist vor dem Lernen

Entdecke direkt den nächsten Lernkurs. Weitere Inhalte erscheinen, wenn Du weiter nach unten scrollst.

Zur MOOCwiki-Hauptseite

Mediathek

Suche verfeinern

Dein Lernplan bestimmt, was oben steht. Alle anderen Inhalte bleiben erreichbar. Seitenaufrufe beeinflussen die Auswahl nicht.

Inhalte werden geladen ...

Mediathek wird aus dem Wiki geladen ...