English:Non-fiction synthesis and source evaluation - English Year 6
Introduction
Become an evidence editor. Why does the Moon appear to change shape, and how is a lunar eclipse different? Use three real educational sources to practise labelling, paraphrasing, corroboration and a cautious synthesis. The main learning goal is how to research and communicate, not how many astronomy facts you can memorise.
Success criteria. Prepare a three-source brief with author or organisation, date, evidence, purpose and corroboration; write an original synthesis; compare conflicting claims; identify an explicit evidence gap. Check the precise claim rather than trusting appearance or counting how many pages repeat it.
The sources were reviewed on 12 November 2026. Dates and calendars can change; distinguish an article update, a site footer and your access date. No invented learner observations or claims of independent measurement are supplied.
Record source identity, purpose and the claim it supports
Begin with a focused question. Our brief asks how ordinary Moon phases differ from a lunar eclipse. Avoid expanding it into every fact about astronomy. Give each source a label so the reader can tell where a particular explanation comes from.
| Source | Identity and purpose | Date information checked | Useful contribution and limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | NASA Space Place: What Are the Moon’s Phases?; explanation for children and educators | Article update 12 June 2023; site footer also displays 31 July 2026 | Explains reflected sunlight and changing views; explicitly distinguishes approximately 27.3-day orbit from 29.5-day phase cycle |
| B | European Space Agency Kids: Moon phases; explanation for children | Dated 15 November 2004 | Describes reflected light and phases; its wording about 27 and 29.5 days needs careful comparison rather than silent copying |
| C | Royal Museums Greenwich / Royal Observatory: Lunar eclipse guide; public explanation and observing information | Accessed 12 November 2026; a specific article-update date was not established in this review | Explains Earth’s shadow and orbital tilt; event times are specific to dates and locations |
Separate dates with different jobs. A site-wide footer may concern the website rather than the particular explanation. An access date says when you checked a page, not when its content was written. An older date does not automatically make a stable scientific explanation false, but it gives you a reason to inspect wording and compare the relevant claim.
Label claims as you collect them. A explains that the Moon reflects sunlight and that the visible illuminated portion changes as the Moon moves around Earth. B supports the reflected-light explanation too. C explains the distinct case in which the Moon enters Earth’s shadow. These contributions help answer one question, but do not make every incidental statement on every page equally checked.
Record the kind of evidence. These are institutional educational explanations using models and images. They are useful reference sources for this task, but they are not a set of measurements made by you. A named organisation is more traceable than an anonymous post; it is not an automatic guarantee that every sentence is unambiguous or perfectly current.
Read the diagram as a model. The upper part presents changing Sun–Earth–Moon arrangements, while the lower strip labels appearances from new through full and back to new. Its objects and distances are not drawn to real scale. It helps organise an explanation; it does not supply a dated series of a learner’s observations or prove that the Moon itself changes physical shape.
A working source note. Write the label, exact page title, organisation, URL, relevant date information, purpose, one concise paraphrased claim and a limit. Return to the actual page if you are unsure. Do not fill an unknown update date with a guessed recent year just to make the table look complete.
Resolve an apparent conflict and test corroboration
An actual wording problem is useful evidence work. Source A distinguishes two periods: about 27.3 days for an orbit and about 29.5 days between successive new moons. B first gives roughly 27 days for rotation and travel around Earth, then later uses 29.5 days in describing motion around Earth in a phase-month explanation. Do not report these as three identical measurements or hide the awkward wording.
Clarify what the numbers refer to. The orbital period and the repeating phase cycle use different reference relationships. Earth also travels around the Sun, so returning to the same phase takes longer than one orbit relative to the distant stars. For this precise question, A’s explicit distinction is clearer than B’s compressed final wording. This is a claim-specific judgement, not a verdict that every ESA resource is unreliable.
| Claim card | Proposed claim | Source-based evaluation |
|---|---|---|
| C1 | The Moon produces the visible moonlight itself | A and B instead explain reflected sunlight |
| C2 | Ordinary phases are changing views of the illuminated portion | A explains the geometry; B supports the reflected-light account |
| C3 | Every crescent is caused by Earth’s shadow | Confuses ordinary phases with the eclipse mechanism described by C |
| C4 | An orbit and a new-moon-to-new-moon cycle must have identical durations | A explicitly distinguishes the two; B’s wording must not erase that distinction |
| C5 | Three pages repeating a claim automatically prove it | Agreement needs relevant support and a check for shared or copied origins |
Two conflicting teaching claims. Imagine a fictional post X says that every crescent is Earth’s shadow, while post Y says we see a changing fraction of the Moon’s sunlit portion. Y is better supported for ordinary phases by A’s explanation and B’s reflected-light account. C helps show why an eclipse is a different alignment. These posts are invented examples; the course is not attributing them to real pupils or organisations.
Corroboration is more than a vote. A repeated claim may come from a copied sentence, a shared image or one original source. Three organisations do not automatically provide three independent measurement series. Check whether each source actually supports the same precise claim and what kind of support it offers. C’s explanation of eclipses is not a second measurement of A’s 27.3-day orbital value.
ESA’s original Paxi and Our Moon: Phases and Eclipses is an animation intended for ages six to twelve. Compare its modelled positions with the phase diagram and distinguish phases from eclipses. Animation compresses time and uses simplified objects; it does not record a real month passing in a few minutes.
Keep the conclusion proportionate. Explain which claim is better supported, by which source and for which question. You can identify a wording ambiguity without treating a whole institution as worthless. You can also reject an unsupported post without pretending that attractive graphics alone prove the alternative.
Write an original synthesis and a transparent research brief
Paraphrase meaning, not just individual words. Read a relevant passage, identify its main point, set it aside and explain the idea in a new structure. Then compare with the source for accuracy. Replacing a few words while retaining the source’s sentence pattern is not a strong independent paraphrase. Keep attribution even when the wording is your own.
Original synthesis model. NASA Space Place and ESA Kids explain ordinary phases through reflected sunlight and our changing view of the illuminated part of the Moon. The Royal Observatory’s guide distinguishes a lunar eclipse, when the Moon enters Earth’s shadow. NASA also separates the orbital period from the longer phase cycle. The older ESA page’s compressed wording needs that clarification rather than being treated as an identical numerical account.
Why this is synthesis. The paragraph combines contributions to one explanation, rather than giving three unrelated miniature reviews. It labels the organisations, distinguishes agreement from a wording issue and keeps the eclipse account separate from ordinary phases. It does not say that the learner personally measured an orbit or that every source was independently produced from new observations.

A photograph also has a source and method. The full-Moon image has a named creator and a dated description. Stacking frames is part of its stated production method. That does not make it a photograph of an invented event, but it matters when describing what it records. One full-Moon image cannot by itself establish the complete sequence or duration of all phases.
| Brief section | Required content | Worked check |
|---|---|---|
| R1 focused question | State exactly what is being investigated | Ordinary phases compared with lunar eclipses, not all astronomy |
| R2 three-source ledger | Give identities, dates, purposes, claims and limits | A, B and C remain distinguishable, including unknown date information |
| R3 claim–evidence–source table | Link each important statement to appropriate support | C1–C5 avoid counting repetition as proof |
| R4 original synthesis | Combine at least two sources in your own wording | Preserve phase/eclipse distinction and the numerical wording issue |
| R5 evaluation and evidence gap | Explain a claim-specific judgement and what is missing | No learner observation series or measurement-method record is supplied here |
Name the evidence gap specifically. This brief supplies educational explanations, not your own dated observations from a known location or a record of how orbital periods were measured. You cannot claim to have measured the periods by reading the pages. If the research question required local visibility on a particular future date, these general explanations alone would not settle it. State what additional appropriate information would be needed, without inventing it.
Handle time-sensitive material carefully. C’s event calendar concerns particular dates and places. An event listed as future in an old screenshot may now be past. Do not copy a 2026 viewing time into a new future calendar without checking the current source and location. The course does not require an outdoor observing task.
Final writing task. Submit a research brief with R1–R5, an original synthesis and an explicit comparison of the two conflicting teaching claims. Explain the organisation, date, evidence, purpose and corroboration of all three sources. Keep a draft and a final version so the reader can see how you corrected copying, ambiguity or overconfidence.
Interactive Tasks
Quiz: Test Your Knowledge
What is the focused research question? (How ordinary Moon phases differ from a lunar eclipse) (!Every fact about every planet) (!Whether a photograph proves all possible claims) (!Which page has the most decorative headings)
Which date statement is accurate for A? (Its article update and site footer have different jobs) (!Every date on the page is the article’s publication date) (!The access date proves when the article was written) (!An unknown date should be invented)
How does A distinguish the two periods? (About 27.3 days for an orbit and 29.5 days for the phase cycle) (!Both are exactly 27 days in every sense) (!The phase cycle takes only one day) (!A learner measured them merely by opening the page)
What should happen with B’s compressed wording? (Compare its context with A’s explicit distinction) (!Hide it and say every source is identical) (!Declare every ESA resource false) (!Copy only the sentence that suits the argument)
Which claim is better supported for ordinary phases? (Our view of the Moon’s illuminated portion changes) (!Every crescent is Earth’s shadow) (!The Moon changes its physical shape every month) (!A photograph alone measures every phase duration)
Why does C help the comparison? (It explains the separate Earth-shadow eclipse mechanism) (!It independently measures A’s orbital value here) (!It proves every anonymous post) (!Its calendar applies forever at every location)
What is the problem with three copied posts? (Their agreement may trace back to one unsupported origin) (!They automatically provide three independent experiments) (!They become correct once the same picture is repeated) (!Their font proves technical authority)
What does strong paraphrasing require? (New structure, faithful meaning and attribution) (!Changing a few adjectives while keeping the source sentence) (!Removing attribution because words were changed) (!Adding a stronger claim to sound confident)
What does the full-Moon photograph establish? (A named creator’s dated image with a stated stacking method) (!The learner’s current local observations) (!The entire phase cycle from one image alone) (!That all lunar images are invented)
Which evidence gap is explicit? (No learner observation series or measurement-method record is supplied) (!No source has any identity) (!Every claim lacks all support) (!The sources prove a complete future local calendar)
Memory Game
| Synthesis | Combining sources into one connected account |
| Paraphrase | A faithful idea expressed in a new wording and structure |
| Attribution | Identifying where an explanation or claim comes from |
| Corroboration | Checking relevant support rather than counting repetition |
| Purpose | What a source is trying to do for its audience |
| Evidence gap | Specific information needed but not supplied |
| Qualification | A limit that keeps a conclusion proportionate |
Drag and Drop
| A article date versus footer | Different dates with different meanings |
| B 27 and 29.5 wording | A context issue needing precise comparison |
| C Earth’s shadow explanation | The distinct lunar-eclipse mechanism |
| Three copied posts | Apparent agreement without automatic independence |
| R5 no observation series | An explicit limit on what the brief can claim |
Crossword Puzzle
| SYNTHESIS | One connected account using multiple sources |
| PARAPHRASE | Faithful independent re-expression |
| ATTRIBUTION | Identification of a source |
| CORROBORATION | Checking support across sources |
| PURPOSE | The source’s intended job |
| EVIDENCE | Support relevant to a claim |
LearningApps
Optional extra practice. Choose an appropriate activity with your teacher. If the external collection is unavailable, use the native activities and independent tasks in this course.
Cloze Text
Open Tasks
Easy
- Three-source identity: Record A, B and C with organisation, page title, purpose, date information and a relevant limit.
- Diagram and photograph: Explain what the phase diagram and dated full-Moon image can and cannot establish.
- Period distinction: Explain the 27.3/29.5 distinction without silently treating B’s wording as identical.
- Compare the teaching posts: Evaluate fictional X and Y for ordinary phases using labelled source support.
Standard
- Claim table: Complete a claim–evidence–source table and flag statements supported by only one selected source.
- Original synthesis: Combine at least two actual sources in your own wording, preserving the relevant distinctions and attribution.
- Three-source research brief: Submit R1–R5 with organisation/date/evidence/purpose/corroboration evaluation for all three sources.
- Explicit evidence gap: State one precise missing record and explain why the current brief cannot claim to supply it.
Advanced
- Apparent agreement audit: Trace how repeated claims or shared materials could create agreement without independent measurement.
- Claim-specific reliability: Explain why A is clearer for the period distinction without calling every other statement or ESA resource worthless.
- Date and calendar revision: Correct a brief that confuses footer, article and access dates or treats past event times as a future local calendar.
- Final research dossier: Present source notes, draft/final synthesis, conflict evaluation and an honestly limited conclusion with a next research question.
Learning Check
- Source evaluation ledger: Evaluate all three actual sources.
- Conflicting claim judgement: Evaluate fictional posts X and Y.
- Numerical wording comparison: Explain the actual source distinction.
- Original connected synthesis: Write an attributed paragraph combining sources.
- Images and evidence gap: State what the supplied material does not provide.
- Complete research brief: Submit and audit R1–R5.
Worked checks and assessment guidance
- A NASA children’s explanation distinguishes article update 12 June 2023 from site footer 31 July 2026. B ESA Kids is dated 15 November 2004 and needs context around its period wording. C Royal Observatory explains eclipses and includes date/location-specific information; no specific article-update date was established here. Name organisation, date information, purpose, evidence and relevant corroboration rather than trust appearance alone.
- Y’s changing view of a sunlit portion is better supported for ordinary phases by A and B. C describes the different Earth-shadow eclipse mechanism. X’s every-crescent-shadow claim confuses those mechanisms. These are original fictional posts, not claims attributed to real pupils or organisations.
- A explicitly gives about 27.3 days for an orbit and 29.5 days from new moon to new moon. B first discusses roughly 27 days, then compresses 29.5 days into an around-Earth phase-month account. Clarify the different reference relationships and retain the wording issue; do not present identical measurements or condemn every ESA resource.
- Link reflected sunlight/changing view with the separate eclipse mechanism, identify which organisations support the statements and retain the period clarification where relevant. Use an original structure, not a few swapped words. Three organisations or repeated posts do not automatically mean independent observational confirmation.
- The diagram is not to scale or a learner observation record. FullMoon2010 is a named dated twenty-frame stack, not today’s phase or proof of a whole cycle. No learner’s dated observation series or orbital measurement-method record is supplied. A future local-visibility question would need additional appropriate information.
- Include focused question, three-source ledger, claim/evidence/source table, original synthesis, claim-specific evaluation and an explicit gap. Preserve the distinction among article/footer/access dates, avoid unsupported local calendars, retain draft/final evidence and explain why your conclusion follows from the sources actually checked.
Learning evidence
Keep the three-source ledger, claim–evidence–source table, draft and final synthesis, comparison of fictional X/Y, date checks and a specific evidence-gap statement. Do not describe reading or a model as a measurement you personally performed.
OER and Wikipedia
Reviewed 12 November 2026. Department for Education: English programmes of study supplies the Upper KS2 non-fiction reading, comparison, composition and evaluation context.
The three evaluated primary educational sources are A: NASA Space Place, What Are the Moon’s Phases?, B: European Space Agency Kids, Moon phases and C: Royal Museums Greenwich / Royal Observatory, lunar eclipse guide. Their date and purpose distinctions are discussed in the course; incidental calendar or frequency claims are not all independently validated here.
Original embedded ESA: Paxi and Our Moon, Phases and Eclipses is described by the official ESA education page as intended for ages 6–12. The research question, ledger, claim cards, fictional conflicting posts, synthesis and tasks are original teaching material. Images are unchanged and interpreted with their source limits.
Moon phases en.jpg, Orion 8, CC BY-SA 3.0. Unchanged.
FullMoon2010.jpg, Gregory H. Revera, CC BY-SA 3.0. Unchanged.
Linked learning areas
aiMOOC Projects
Schulfach+


aiMOOCs


aiMOOC Projekte


MOOCwiki · Deutsch
Nach dem Lernen ist vor dem Lernen
Entdecke direkt den nächsten Lernkurs. Weitere Inhalte erscheinen, wenn Du weiter nach unten scrollst.
Zur MOOCwiki-HauptseiteMediathek
Mediathek wird aus dem Wiki geladen ...
Keine passenden Inhalte gefunden. Bitte ändere Suche oder Filter.
NEWSLernweltNOAH fragen