English:Metaethics and the meaning of moral language - Ethics Year 9
Introduction
Separate questions about an event, questions about what should happen and questions about what a moral judgement means.
Ask three different questions
Consider an exchange between two pupils. “The book was due at noon” describes a circumstance that a record could confirm. “It was wrong to break the promise for convenience” evaluates a choice. “What makes a judgement like that true or justified?” asks about the status of a moral judgement.
Normative ethics asks which actions and principles are right or what we ought to do. Metaethics asks what moral statements mean, whether they can be true or false and what could make a moral judgement true. A moral realist can think some moral judgements state facts, so the distinction here is between a descriptive claim about the event and a moral evaluation of it.

Compare three interpretations of a judgement
Use the same statement in each case. “Breaking a promise for convenience is wrong.”
On the moral realist view used here, some moral claims are true independently of whether a person or group approves of them. The speaker is making a claim that could be true even if everyone in the room disagreed with it. The details of the promise can still matter to the judgement.
On one form of moral relativism, the truth or falsity of a moral claim depends on the relevant standard. The claim about the promise might be true according to the shared commitment being applied. The claim that people in a group disagree describes their beliefs. It does not by itself establish that moral truth is relative or identify which standard should apply.
An expressivist accounts for moral judgement by looking at the practical stance expressed, such as rejecting promise-breaking for convenience. Expressing disapproval differs from reporting the fact “I feel disapproval”. Expressivism has several forms. This lesson uses an introductory interpretation that draws attention to what the speaker is doing with moral language.
The Crash Course film introduces metaethical questions and compares terminology such as moral realism and cultural relativism. Classifications vary across introductions. Use this lesson’s stated definitions when answering its tasks. The text and worked examples give a full alternative to the film.
Test a short case about promising
Fictional case. Jules promised to give back a borrowed book at noon so that Alex could use it for an afternoon project. Jules keeps it longer to avoid making a second trip, even though returning it is possible. Both agree that the book was due at noon. They differ on whether breaking the promise for convenience was wrong.
Write down a fact each shares, the normative issue and the metaethical issue. A realist could ask whether one account of the promise is morally true independently of Jules’s approval. A relativist might ask which standards matter to the students’ arrangement and whether the judgement is true relative to those standards. An expressivist could ask what practical commitment each assessment expresses, for example a commitment to object when people put convenience before an accepted promise.
A new fact could change a normative judgement. If returning the book on time put someone at risk during an emergency, that matters to what Jules should do. It does not by itself decide which explanation of moral language is best.
Assess what each view explains
Realism explains why people may think a whole community can be wrong about a moral issue. It faces a question about how people can know moral truths and settle disputes. Relativism can explain why standards matter to judgements, while facing the question of which standard to use when people belong to several groups or disagree about the standards within one group.
Expressivism highlights why moral language can guide choices and show what people stand for. A challenge for simple versions is to explain how a moral claim keeps its meaning within an argument. “If breaking a promise for convenience is wrong, asking another person to do so may also be wrong.” The speaker uses the first judgement as part of a conditional without directly asserting it. A successful account of moral language must explain how people can reason consistently with such sentences.
Disagreement gives the theories something to explain. The fact that people disagree leaves all three approaches open until further reasons are considered.
Transfer the distinction to a queue
New fictional case. At a ticket desk, Sam joins a friend who has waited ten minutes and goes ahead of other people. Two witnesses agree on the order in which people arrived. One says that moving ahead was unfair. Another argues that friends may be allowed to join the line under a clearly announced rule, but nobody has checked what the sign says.
Give one descriptive claim about the event, one normative question and one metaethical question. Explain how two of the three views could interpret “Moving ahead was unfair.” Identify something to check, such as the announced rule or what other people understood, and say whether that would change the action judgement or establish the meaning of all moral statements.

Aim for eight of ten quick checks. Explain one position and evaluate what it helps explain and what remains challenging.
Interactive Tasks
Quiz: Test Your Knowledge
Which is a descriptive claim about the book case? (The book was due at noon.) (!Keeping it longer for convenience is wrong.) (!Jules should give more weight to the promise.) (!The lending system should treat both pupils fairly.)
Which is a normative question? (Should Jules keep the book past the time promised?) (!Was the book due at noon or at one?) (!Do moral judgements express practical commitments?) (!What could make a moral statement true?)
Which question is metaethical? (What makes a moral judgement true or false, if it can be either?) (!When did Jules agree to return the book?) (!Would returning the book be inconvenient today?) (!How many pupils share the book?)
How does the form of moral realism used here interpret a moral claim? (It could be true independently of whether people approve of it.) (!It becomes true whenever most people agree with it.) (!It only reports a passing feeling.) (!It must have the same answer even when relevant circumstances differ.)
What does one form of moral relativism in this lesson propose? (A moral claim may be true relative to the standard being used.) (!Every value judgement is a report about the time on a clock.) (!The latest opinion automatically makes a judgement correct for everyone.) (!The fact that people have different beliefs proves directly which action is right.)
Which describes the introductory expressivist interpretation? (The judgement can express a practical stance against breaking a promise for convenience.) (!The judgement always reports a time of day.) (!The judgement tells us whether a local standard was written on a sign.) (!The judgement simply counts how many people dislike the action.)
Why does the emergency matter to the promise case? (A new fact can affect what Jules should do without settling the theory of moral language.) (!The emergency makes all earlier descriptive claims false.) (!Any change of circumstance proves that realism cannot be true.) (!It fixes the meaning of every moral judgement.)
What is a challenge for a simple expressivist explanation? (Explain how moral claims can be used consistently inside conditionals.) (!Explain why a catalogue names the book’s author.) (!Count the people who agree to join a line.) (!Determine whether every library closes at the same time.)
What might a relativist need to address when standards conflict? (Which standard should be used when different groups or members disagree?) (!How many minutes does a clock show?) (!What is the colour of the loan receipt?) (!Whether an argument can have any conclusion.)
What do the two witnesses’ reports establish in the new case? (They agree on the order of arrival, which does not settle every judgement about fairness.) (!They prove everyone agreed to let friends go ahead.) (!They settle whether moral conclusions depend on standards.) (!They prove that a sign gave advance permission.)
Memory Game
| metaethics | inquiry into the meaning and status of moral claims |
| normative | concerned with what people should do or value |
| realism | here, the view that some moral truths are independent of people’s approval |
| relativism | here, understanding moral truth relative to a relevant standard |
| expressivism | explaining moral judgement through a practical stance it expresses |
| conditional | a statement that links what follows to an if-clause |
Drag and Drop
| The book was due at noon | Describe an event or circumstance |
| Should Jules return it now? | Ask a normative question |
| What would make a moral judgement true? | Ask a metaethical question |
| This could be true even if people disapprove | Give a realist interpretation |
| The judgement expresses a stance against the act | Give an expressivist interpretation |
Crossword Puzzle
| Metaethics | Inquiry into the meaning and status of moral judgements |
| Normative | Concerned with what ought to be done |
| Realism | The view examined here that some moral truths are independent of approval |
| Relativism | The view examined here that moral judgements depend on a relevant standard |
| Expressivism | A view explaining moral judgements in terms of the practical stance expressed |
| Conditional | An if-then statement |
LearningApps
Optional extra practice. Choose an appropriate activity with your teacher. If the external collection is unavailable, use the native activities and independent tasks in this course.
Cloze Text
Open Tasks
Easy
- Identify a factual claim: State one detail both pupils agree about.
- Write a moral judgement: Give a sentence evaluating breaking the promise.
- Ask about meaning: Turn your judgement into a question about what moral words mean.
- Describe a new circumstance: Explain why an emergency may matter to what Jules should do.
Standard
- Compare two interpretations: Explain how a realist and an expressivist might interpret the same judgement.
- Connect standards and truth: Explain the difference between recording different beliefs and making a relativist claim.
- Use the film or course: Explain the difference between a normative and a metaethical question.
- Look inside a conditional: Explain why using a moral claim after if does not directly assert the claim.
Advanced
- Transfer to the queue: State the descriptive, normative and metaethical issues and give two interpretations.
- Assess one view: Describe what a chosen view helps explain and one challenge it faces.
- Distinguish stance and report: Explain how expressing a commitment differs from reporting that you have a feeling.
- Test a conclusion from disagreement: Explain why a difference of opinion cannot by itself settle the metaethical debate.
Learning Check
- Separate the three questions: Give an example of a factual, normative and metaethical question about the promise.
- Explain a realist view: Why can people be mistaken about a moral claim on the realist view?
- Explain a form of relativism: How can a judgement be understood relative to a standard?
- Explain an expressivist view: What is the difference between expressing a stance and reporting a feeling?
- Assess a view: What is one strength and one challenge of relativism?
- Apply the distinction to fairness in a queue: What could further evidence settle and what remains a metaethical question?
Worked checks and assessment guidance
- Ask when the book was due, whether Jules should keep it longer and what would make a judgement about breaking the promise true. Each asks for a different kind of answer.
- Some moral truths can hold independently of whether a person or group approves. Evidence and argument can still matter to discovering what is justified and how circumstances affect a decision.
- Its truth is evaluated in relation to a relevant standard. Describing disagreement tells us which beliefs differ. It does not establish that the theory is true or say which standard to apply.
- The judgement may express a commitment against breaking promises for convenience. A statement that I feel disapproval instead gives a report about my psychological state. A simple expressivist account must also explain reasoning with the judgement inside conditionals.
- It draws attention to how standards inform judgements. When several standards apply or members disagree about their group’s standards, the view needs an account of which reference standard is relevant.
- Checking signage and shared expectations can help answer whether Sam acted fairly. It does not settle whether a fairness judgement expresses a stance, is true relative to a standard or can be true independently of approval.
Learning evidence
Reach eight out of ten quick checks. Distinguish questions about fact, action and moral language, then evaluate one theory and apply it to a fresh case.
OER and Wikipedia
David O. Brink, Moral Realism and the Foundations of Ethics, is a primary defence of one form of realism. Allan Gibbard, Wise Choices, Apt Feelings, develops a theory of normative judgement in terms of accepting norms. A. J. Ayer’s Language, Truth and Logic, chapter 6, is an earlier emotivist approach. James Rachels, The Challenge of Cultural Relativism, addresses the argument from cultural disagreement. The book and queue cases are fictional and were written for this course.
Library shelves by Quadell, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons. Displayed unchanged.
Queue of people by mycurrency.com, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons. Displayed unchanged.
Metaethics: Crash Course Philosophy #32 by CrashCourse. The course text supplies its own definitions and examples.
Linked learning areas
aiMOOC Projects
Schulfach+


aiMOOCs


aiMOOC Projekte


MOOCwiki · Deutsch
Nach dem Lernen ist vor dem Lernen
Entdecke direkt den nächsten Lernkurs. Weitere Inhalte erscheinen, wenn Du weiter nach unten scrollst.
Zur MOOCwiki-HauptseiteMediathek
Mediathek wird aus dem Wiki geladen ...
Keine passenden Inhalte gefunden. Bitte ändere Suche oder Filter.
NEWSLernweltNOAH fragen