Zum Inhalt springen

English:Free will, choice and moral responsibility - Ethics Year 9

Aus MOOCsWiki Staging
aiMOOC-Siegel aiMOOC

Free will, choice and moral responsibility - Ethics Year 9

QR-Code



Introduction

Compare three accounts of free will and use what someone knew, intended and could reasonably do to assess responsibility.


Distinguish causes, pressure and knowledge

A cause helps explain why an action happened. A person can act for reasons, such as wanting to keep a promise or wanting to avoid an argument. Those reasons can be part of a causal explanation. Coercion is serious pressure, such as a credible threat, that restricts how freely someone can decide. A person’s knowledge about likely consequences also matters to a judgement of responsibility.

Determinism is the view that the complete prior state of the world and its laws together fix what happens next. It differs from the idea that the same outcome would occur regardless of what someone chooses or does. In a deterministic account, deliberation and action can be among the causes. Consider a person who checks a closing time and decides to start earlier. Their checking and decision can help explain why they arrive on time.

An aerial view shows a paved road dividing into two branches.
A fork in a road is a way to picture different courses of action. The road itself cannot settle whether a person could choose differently under exactly the same conditions.


Compare three positions on free will

Libertarian free will combines the claim that people sometimes act freely with the view that this freedom is incompatible with determinism. Many libertarians emphasise genuine alternatives in at least some choices. A chance event alone would not give someone control. The account still has to explain what makes an action the person’s own.

Hard determinism accepts determinism and holds that it rules out free will in the relevant strong sense. It challenges the idea that people deserve blame independently of the causes of their actions. A hard determinist can still give reasons for preventing harm, supporting people to change, making repairs and learning from decisions.

Compatibilism holds that free will and determinism can coexist. A compatibilist might ask whether an action follows the person’s own deliberation and whether they can respond to reasons without coercion. David Hume’s account of liberty and necessity is an important historical example, while later compatibilists develop different accounts of control. The Crash Course film introduces compatibilism and alternative possibilities. The written definitions and cases provide a full alternative to the film.

A painted portrait shows David Hume in a red coat with gold decoration.
David Hume argued that liberty and causal necessity can be understood together. The portrait is by Allan Ramsay.


Work through a pressured team decision

Fictional case. A project leader tells Nia to sign a record claiming all the work is finished. Nia knows that one important part is incomplete. The leader threatens to exclude Nia from the team and persuade other members to stop working with her. The leader has controlled assignments before. Nia signs to avoid the threatened exclusion. We do not yet know what safe options she could see at the time.

A libertarian analysis asks whether Nia had a genuine alternative that she could control. Even if she could have refused, strong pressure can still reduce how far she is blameworthy. A hard determinist asks what conditions caused the decision and questions ultimate blame. In practical terms, stop the pressure, correct the record and make sure team members can ask for help. A compatibilist asks how far Nia acted for reasons she could consider and how far coercion undermined her control. The physical ability to refuse does not tell us whether Nia had a fair opportunity to decide freely.

To judge the case carefully, distinguish the risk she believed she faced, the leader’s control over assignments, whether Nia understood the form and whether a supportive adult was reachable. These are questions about the circumstances. The short scenario cannot decide which broad theory of free will is true.


Test an explanation and a counterargument

Suppose the leader had only stated a personal preference, with no threat or loss of access, and Nia had signed because she wanted to save time. A compatibilist may see more scope for responsible choice in that version. A hard determinist can still explain both actions causally while distinguishing the appropriate practical responses. A libertarian might ask in each case whether any alternatives were genuinely open.

One criticism of compatibilism is that actions can express our desires even when we have little control over how those desires developed. A reply is that meaningful responsibility may depend on understanding reasons and exercising control in the situation. Explain why ordinary pressure, mistaken information and credible threats could affect that control differently. This reply has to be argued for, even when it fits an example.


Transfer to a repair workshop

New fictional case. Chris moves a borrowed toolbox to another room so a team can start an activity. Another group is delayed. A friend says Chris ignored a written instruction. The wording was partly covered, and we do not know whether Chris had heard the instruction earlier or could easily have checked with staff.

State what happened, what Chris might reasonably have known and which options were available. Compare a version in which Chris deliberately ignored a clear instruction with one in which Chris made a reasonable mistake. Apply one view, explain how a competing view may respond and say which missing fact matters most. A fair step might include returning the toolbox, clarifying the shared instructions and asking what support would prevent a repeat.

Aim for eight of ten quick checks. Explain all three positions accurately, then give a qualified judgement about one fictional case with a counterargument.


Interactive Tasks


Quiz: Test Your Knowledge

What does determinism mean in this lesson? (The complete previous conditions and the laws fix what happens next.) (!Whatever people do, their actions cannot affect any outcome.) (!People can know all future events in advance.) (!The events of the past never influence decisions.)



Which statement expresses libertarian free will? (People sometimes act freely and that freedom is incompatible with determinism.) (!All actions are determined and free will in the strong sense is impossible.) (!Determinism is compatible with acting freely when a person acts from their reasons.) (!Any random event counts as a free choice.)



Which statement expresses hard determinism? (Determinism is true and rules out free will in the strong sense.) (!People are only responsible when a school has written a rule.) (!People can never learn from earlier decisions.) (!Determinism is compatible with all forms of freedom.)



What can a compatibilist hold? (Acting freely and a deterministic world can be compatible.) (!Freedom always requires chance to decide the action.) (!A person’s knowledge is irrelevant to responsibility.) (!Feeling a desire proves in every case that a choice is free.)



What distinguishes Nia’s main case from the alternative? (In the main case she faces a serious threat that may restrict her control.) (!In both cases the leader is confirmed to have lost all influence.) (!In the first case she had no knowledge that the record was inaccurate.) (!In the alternative case the leader’s pressure becomes more serious.)



Why does it matter what Nia knew about her options? (It affects how far she could deliberate and respond to reasons under pressure.) (!It proves whether the entire universe is deterministic.) (!Any physical possibility proves a decision is free enough for full blame.) (!The person who presents a choice always decides what is morally true.)



Why can a hard determinist still recommend correcting a false record? (Responding to errors can prevent harm and help change what happens later.) (!Every response must produce the same result.) (!A useful correction proves that every choice is uncaused.) (!Changing the record settles a debate about free will.)



Which is a genuine objection to some compatibilist accounts? (A person may act from desires whose formation they had little control over.) (!The word compatibilism has many letters.) (!A team has more than one member.) (!The toolbox was borrowed rather than bought.)



What should be checked in the toolbox example? (Whether Chris could see or already knew the instruction and had a reasonable way to check.) (!Whether every team in the country has identical tools.) (!How large the room is compared with the sports hall.) (!Whether the instruction was printed in the same font as other signs.)



Why does responsibility analysis distinguish explanation and excuse? (A cause can help explain an action while further facts affect how much blame is appropriate.) (!Every caused action deserves exactly the same blame.) (!Any explanation automatically removes all responsibility.) (!A judgement of responsibility can ignore knowledge and pressure.)





Memory Game

determinism prior conditions and laws fix what happens next
libertarianism here, some free choices are possible and incompatible with determinism
compatibilism free will and determinism can coexist
coercion serious pressure that restricts how freely someone decides
deliberation weighing reasons before acting
responsibility being appropriately answerable for an action





Drag and Drop

Check whether an alternative was genuinely open Ask a libertarian question
Explain causes without requiring ultimate blame Apply hard determinism
Ask whether someone acted through their own reasons without coercion Apply a compatibilist test
Ask whether the person saw the instruction Check knowledge
Correct the record and reduce the risk of new pressure Plan a practical response





Crossword Puzzle

Determinism Prior conditions and laws fix what happens next
Libertarianism The position here that free will exists and excludes determinism
Compatibilism The view that free will can coexist with determinism
Coercion Serious pressure, such as a credible threat
Deliberation Weighing reasons before acting
Responsibility Being answerable for an action





LearningApps

Optional extra practice. Choose an appropriate activity with your teacher. If the external collection is unavailable, use the native activities and independent tasks in this course.


Cloze Text

Complete the explanation.
The view that prior conditions and laws fix the next event is

. The view studied here that free will exists and is incompatible with it is

. The view that free will can coexist with it is

. A serious threat can amount to

. Weighing reasons is

. Being answerable concerns

.



Open Tasks


Easy

  1. Identify a reason: Give one reason Nia had for signing.
  2. State one uncertainty: Name one fact missing about what Nia could safely do.
  3. Distinguish two situations: Explain the change between a preference and a serious threat.
  4. Explain a term: Say why determinism does not imply that deliberation cannot affect what happens.


Standard

  1. Apply a compatibilist account: Explain how coercion could reduce Nia’s control.
  2. Apply libertarian reasoning: Explain what a genuine alternative would mean in this case.
  3. Use the film or written definitions: Compare two views without claiming that the case proves either.
  4. Explain a practical response: State how someone could address the false record without relying on ultimate blame.


Advanced

  1. Transfer to the toolbox: Evaluate Chris’s responsibility under two versions of what Chris knew.
  2. Address an objection: Explain the worry about how someone’s desires developed and give a possible reply.
  3. Separate three issues: Identify a cause, a pressure and relevant knowledge in the team case.
  4. Give a qualified judgement: Use one view, respond to another and name evidence that might change your assessment.



Learning Check

  1. Differentiate the three theories: How do the positions relate free will to determinism?
  2. Distinguish an action from its causes: Why can a decision still make a difference in a deterministic account?
  3. Apply knowledge and coercion: Why should the threat affect the assessment of Nia’s choice?
  4. Evaluate a compatibilist reply: What is one objection to judging freedom by the person’s reasons?
  5. Explain practical responsibility: How can someone address the false record without settling the free-will debate?
  6. Transfer to the toolbox: Why distinguish deliberate disregard from a reasonable mistake?


Worked checks and assessment guidance

  1. Libertarian free will affirms some freedom and treats it as incompatible with determinism. Hard determinism accepts determinism and rules out freedom in that strong sense. Compatibilism holds that determinism and meaningful freedom can coexist.
  2. The decision and the deliberation can form part of the explanation of what happens. A person can respond to new reasons, and changing the facts can change what they decide.
  3. Nia knew the form was inaccurate, but the threat may have narrowed her options and freedom to deliberate. Find out what the leader could do and whether Nia reasonably saw a safe alternative.
  4. A person may act on desires formed without much control. A compatibilist can reply that understanding the facts and being able to respond to reasons now can still matter. More argument is needed about what kind of control is sufficient.
  5. Correct the record, provide a safe route to raise concerns and prevent pressure from recurring. These steps can protect others and make later actions better informed whether or not ultimate blame is justified.
  6. Knowledge, notice and feasible alternatives affect the assessment. Check whether Chris saw or reasonably could have checked the instruction. A deliberate choice with clear information provides a stronger basis for blame under approaches that emphasise control.


Learning evidence

Reach eight out of ten quick checks. Compare all three positions and give a reasoned responsibility judgement that identifies pressure, knowledge and one uncertainty.


OER and Wikipedia

David Hume, An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, section VIII on liberty and necessity. Robert Kane, The Significance of Free Will, defends a libertarian approach. Baron d’Holbach, The System of Nature, volume I, discusses the rejection of free agency in chapter XI. The team and toolbox cases are fictional teaching examples.

David Hume painted by Allan Ramsay by Allan Ramsay, Public domain, Wikimedia Commons. Displayed unchanged.

Fork in a road by Wikideas1, CC0, Wikimedia Commons. Displayed unchanged.

Compatibilism: Crash Course Philosophy #25 by CrashCourse. The course’s written explanation and case analysis give a complete alternative.


Linked learning areas


aiMOOC Projects



Schulfach+




aiMOOCs



aiMOOC Projekte









MOOCwiki · Deutsch

Nach dem Lernen ist vor dem Lernen

Entdecke direkt den nächsten Lernkurs. Weitere Inhalte erscheinen, wenn Du weiter nach unten scrollst.

Zur MOOCwiki-Hauptseite

Mediathek

Suche verfeinern

Dein Lernplan bestimmt, was oben steht. Alle anderen Inhalte bleiben erreichbar. Seitenaufrufe beeinflussen die Auswahl nicht.

Inhalte werden geladen ...

Mediathek wird aus dem Wiki geladen ...