English:Extended ethical argument and transition project - Ethics Year 9
Introduction
Develop a clear line of ethical reasoning using two verified sources, a fair counterargument and a conclusion that follows from your evidence.
Define the decision and write a provisional conclusion
A sustained argument develops a connected answer to a specific question. Begin by saying what action is proposed, whose interests it affects and which criteria matter. Form a provisional thesis, a clear answer you can revise as evidence appears. Each main paragraph should help establish, qualify or test that answer.
Fictional question. Should a school use an AI system to recommend which pupils could benefit from an offer of tutoring? The tool would make a suggestion to staff. The school has no verified results showing that this particular tool improves support. A provisional conclusion might favour a trial using invented profiles with no consequences for pupils, then require stronger evidence before deciding whether to consider any real use. A different conclusion can also earn full credit when it uses the evidence and answers a serious objection.

Map reasons, evidence and objections
Write your thesis at the top of an argument map. Under it put two or three reasons. Link each reason to evidence and explain the link. Attach an objection to the particular claim it challenges. For example, faster review is a potential benefit because staff could reach a pupil earlier. A list of suggestions is not evidence that earlier tutoring reached the intended pupils. Compare the proposal with teacher review and a route for pupils to request support directly.
Use at least two sources for different purposes. The Department for Education explains privacy considerations for generative AI in schools. It provides a starting point for discussing necessary data and approval if the proposed tool uses that technology. The NIST AI Risk Management Framework introduces broader questions about reliability, fairness and harmful bias. Neither source supplies results about the fictional system. The DfE film explains privacy for educators; the course text gives a written alternative focused on collecting only what is needed and checking who can use it.

Test benefits, privacy and fairness in a worked example
The possible benefit is earlier help. Ask what improvement the school would measure, such as time to an appropriate offer of support. Compare with the usual process. A pupil might need support while submitting little online work because internet access is limited. If the system treats online activity as the main signal, it might overlook that pupil. This gives a concrete reason to check for harmful patterns and offer an independent route for requesting support.
Illustrative test. In two sets of ten invented profiles already marked as needing support, suppose the system misses three in one set and one in the other. That is 3 of 10 compared with 1 of 10. The test shows a difference in this small simulation. It gives a reason to investigate, with no estimate of how common errors would be in the school. No real pupil data are needed to complete the exercise.
Privacy concerns which data are necessary, who can see them and what happens to them afterwards. Fairness concerns who might be repeatedly overlooked and who can challenge a mistake. A meaningful staff review involves time, information and the ability to disagree with a suggestion. A button labelled “review” does little if staff are expected to accept every recommendation.
Write a fair counterargument and revise the conclusion
Counterargument. Requiring additional checks can delay a tool that might help staff offer tutoring earlier. This challenges a genuine cost of postponement. A fair reply can acknowledge that cost, then ask whether targeted teacher review could address urgent needs now while invented-case tests are run. It can also say what evidence would justify changing the recommendation.
Model conclusion. Continue ordinary teacher and pupil referral routes. Consider an invented-profile test of whether suggestions are useful and whether some pupils would be missed. The school should require a separate assessment of the benefits, safeguards and applicable rules before considering actual pupil data or decisions. If evidence shows no meaningful improvement over ordinary review, there is a reason to reject the tool. This conclusion follows the reasons explained earlier and avoids using new evidence at the last moment.
Revise one paragraph for a precise claim, an explanation of what the source can support and a link back to the thesis. Then add a short reflection naming one strong step and one remaining gap.
Complete a new argument and prepare for Year 10
New fictional question. The library has six quiet study desks. Should it allocate them by an online booking system or keep some places for people who arrive without booking? Some pupils have limited internet access outside school. Staff need a workable process and have not measured waiting times. Build a thesis and two reasons, identify what evidence would be needed and answer the strongest objection. Consult at least two appropriate sources for your chosen question and state their limits. Keep facts from the case separate from assumptions.
For the extended response, use about 450 to 650 words if your teacher has given no different length. Include an accurate explanation of one ethical idea, two named sources, a serious counterargument, a reply and a justified conclusion. Add a short source log and reflection. Aim for eight of ten quick checks.
For GCSE Religious Studies in England, ask what route the school actually offers. Check whether it is a full or short course or another arrangement, the examination board and specification code, which religions or themes the school teaches and what kinds of exam questions you will practise. The DfE subject-content document sets national requirements for the qualifications. The school and the exam board are the sources for the route and options that apply to your class.
Interactive Tasks
Quiz: Test Your Knowledge
What does a thesis do? (Give a clear answer to the question that can be revised as evidence develops.) (!List every source without stating a judgement.) (!State the length of the draft.) (!Require the writer to keep their first view whatever happens.)
What should a main paragraph contribute? (A reason, evidence or test that helps develop the line of argument.) (!An unrelated new point simply to increase length.) (!A conclusion about a different school decision.) (!A repetition of the section title without explanation.)
What is a potential benefit in the fictional tutoring case? (A useful recommendation could lead to a timely offer of appropriate support.) (!A recommendation always proves that the pupil received tutoring.) (!Collecting more information always makes the system fairer.) (!Offering support becomes unnecessary once software is installed.)
What can the two invented sets of profiles show? (The simulation missed 3 of 10 and 1 of 10 and can guide further questions.) (!The simulation measures how many real pupils the school misses.) (!The result proves every future suggestion will be reliable.) (!The result establishes that collecting more data is the right remedy.)
What makes staff review meaningful? (Staff have enough information, time and authority to disagree with a suggestion.) (!Staff must accept every recommendation immediately.) (!Having a review button settles whether pupils can challenge a mistake.) (!Staff see no details about what a recommendation means.)
Which is a strong counterargument to postponing the tool? (Extra checks might delay a useful offer of early support.) (!A computer lab has a long corridor.) (!An essay should use more words than the assignment requests.) (!There are six desks in a separate example.)
What is a reasoned response to concern about delay? (Maintain direct support now while evaluating the untested proposal.) (!Treat any delay as proof the software will work.) (!Assume the school already knows every benefit.) (!Stop considering alternatives once a counterargument is raised.)
How should a writer use the NIST framework? (To frame reliability and fairness questions, with separate evidence about the proposed tool.) (!To infer that the fictional school tool has already been tested.) (!To establish the exam board for an English school.) (!To avoid discussing uncertainty in the conclusion.)
What should the school confirm for GCSE Religious Studies? (The route, awarding organisation, specification and options for your class.) (!That every learner in England follows identical options.) (!Only which exam paper has the longest title.) (!The IT supplier’s view of the course.)
Which step strengthens the study-desk argument? (Compare barriers for different pupils and use evidence to justify the booking proposal.) (!Assume internet access is identical for every student.) (!Use the six desks to infer all pupils prefer online booking.) (!Introduce a new policy as the final sentence without explaining it.)
Memory Game
| thesis | the central answer the argument develops |
| evidence | information that can support or challenge a claim |
| fairness | giving due consideration to people affected |
| privacy | appropriate limits on use of personal information |
| counterargument | a reason that challenges a conclusion or step |
| reflection | a short evaluation of strengths and gaps in your work |
Drag and Drop
| State what the school should consider and under what conditions | Write a thesis |
| Say what a test with invented cases shows | Explain the evidence |
| Give the strongest reason that checks may cause delay | State a counterargument |
| Keep existing support available while testing | Reply to the objection |
| Describe a weakness you would investigate | Reflect on the argument |
Crossword Puzzle
| Thesis | The central answer developed in an argument |
| Evidence | Information supporting or challenging a claim |
| Fairness | Giving due consideration to people affected by a decision |
| Privacy | Appropriate limits on use of personal information |
| Counterargument | A reason challenging an argument or conclusion |
| Reflection | Evaluation of the strengths and gaps of your own work |
LearningApps
Optional extra practice. Choose an appropriate activity with your teacher. If the external collection is unavailable, use the native activities and independent tasks in this course.
Cloze Text
Open Tasks
Easy
- State the decision: Describe the school’s proposed use of AI in one precise sentence.
- Write a provisional answer: Give one sentence you would revisit after checking evidence.
- Identify a possible benefit: Describe what earlier support might achieve.
- Name a missing fact: Give one claim about the proposed tool that the school has yet to verify.
Standard
- Map an argument: Link two reasons to a provisional conclusion and identify the evidence each would need.
- Compare two guidance sources: Describe the separate contribution and limit of the DfE guidance and NIST framework.
- Interpret the simulation: Explain 3 of 10 and 1 of 10 without making a claim about real pupils.
- Write an objection and reply: Give the strongest reasonable objection to testing first and respond with reasons.
Advanced
- Write the extended response: Use two relevant sources, an ethical idea, a counterargument and a conclusion supported by your reasons.
- Transfer to study desks: Propose a fair allocation process and explain how you would test it.
- Revise one paragraph: Improve its claim, evidence and explanation, then say what changed.
- Plan the GCSE transition: Record the route information you need to check and where you would get it.
Learning Check
- Define the scope of an argument: What would make the tutoring question precise?
- Use evidence appropriately: What can the two sources support about the AI proposal?
- Recognise a limitation: Does a simulation with two sets of ten establish the level of unfairness in school?
- Answer a serious objection: How could you respond fairly to the concern that waiting may delay support?
- Transfer a line of reasoning: Give a defensible answer to the study-desk question.
- Plan and reflect: Which GCSE information and one drafting gap should you record?
Worked checks and assessment guidance
- Specify that the proposed software recommends an offer to staff, the pupils and staff affected, and the decision between ordinary referral, an invented-data trial or considering wider use after further checks.
- DfE guidance helps identify school privacy questions for generative tools. The NIST framework helps assess reliability and fairness. Evidence about this particular proposal still needs a context-specific evaluation.
- The figures are illustrative. They show that different profiles can experience different results in a small simulation. They give questions to examine and do not establish actual rates for the school.
- Acknowledge that delay can matter. Keep direct referral and teacher review available now. Test with invented profiles while staff gather evidence, and explain what improvement could justify changing the decision.
- Consider a mix of bookings and walk-in access because different pupils face different barriers. Gather evidence on waiting and access, address the objection that unused bookings waste places, and review actual use before making the policy permanent.
- Check the route, board, specification, options and exam questions with the school or awarding organisation. Record one drafting issue, such as needing evidence for a claim or addressing a stronger objection.
Learning evidence
Reach eight out of ten quick checks. Produce a sustained ethical argument using two sources and a counterargument, then justify your conclusion and reflect on one gap.
OER and Wikipedia
Department for Education, Generative AI and data protection in schools, for privacy questions specific to generative AI. NIST, Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework, for questions about reliability, privacy and harmful bias. Department for Education, GCSE Religious Studies subject content, for the qualification framework in England. The school examples and figures are fictional. The exercise uses no pupil data.
Historical computer laboratory by Linda Bartlett (Photographer), Public domain, Wikimedia Commons. Displayed unchanged.
Structured debate diagram by Authors of the study: Eric Bolton, Alex Calderwood, Niles Christensen, Jerome Kafrouni, Iddo Drori, CC BY 4.0, Wikimedia Commons. Displayed unchanged.
Protecting children’s privacy when using Artificial Intelligence by DfE Sector Comms. The written course covers the relevant privacy questions independently.
Linked learning areas
aiMOOC Projects
Schulfach+


aiMOOCs


aiMOOC Projekte


MOOCwiki · Deutsch
Nach dem Lernen ist vor dem Lernen
Entdecke direkt den nächsten Lernkurs. Weitere Inhalte erscheinen, wenn Du weiter nach unten scrollst.
Zur MOOCwiki-HauptseiteMediathek
Mediathek wird aus dem Wiki geladen ...
Keine passenden Inhalte gefunden. Bitte ändere Suche oder Filter.
NEWSLernweltNOAH fragen