Zum Inhalt springen

English:Design & Technology Year 6 - Structural testing and redesign

Aus MOOCsWiki Staging
aiMOOC-Siegel aiMOOC

Design & Technology Year 6 - Structural testing and redesign

QR-Code



Introduction

A pedestrian bridge with diagonal steel members and supports at each end
Look for members joints and supports. This real bridge is a reference for structural ideas, not a structure you should load-test or a safety certificate for a paper model.

Can you improve a model structure and show why the change helps? Learn to compare designs fairly, define a limit before testing, record repeat trials and use evidence for a redesign. The results below are original fictional classroom data, not measured bridges or a test you have already completed. Year 6 is an editorial sequence within England's whole-Key-Stage-2 D&T programme. Any real making or testing requires school approval, supervision and direct teacher observation.


Choose what the structure must do

A model bridge for a classroom display has a purpose: it must span a gap, provide the required usable surface and behave acceptably under an agreed small test. Before choosing a dramatic shape, write design criteria. A criterion is a requirement you can check. In this course's invented comparison, the span is twenty centimetres and the nominal downward deflection limit is ten millimetres. Those are fictional analysis conditions, not instructions to apply a particular mass to a real model.

Distinguish three properties. Strength concerns a structure's ability to resist failure under loading. Stiffness concerns how much it deforms for a stated load. Stability concerns resisting an unwanted change such as toppling, sliding or losing its support arrangement. A model can be strong enough not to break but too flexible for its purpose. Another model can be fairly stiff yet unstable because its supports move.

Deflection is a displacement from a reference position. To compare downward deflection, identify the same point on each prototype and record its unloaded position before adding anything. Compare the later position with that reference. A ruler measures a change in millimetres, not simply the height of the table. Keep your eye aligned with the scale to reduce reading errors, and use a fixed reference rather than a ruler that moves with the model.

Our nominal criterion permits deflection of ten millimetres or less. A recorded eleven millimetres fails that criterion even if the material remains in one piece. Exactly ten is a nominal pass under this declared wording, whereas a different rule saying less than ten would treat the boundary differently. Decide the rule before seeing which model wins. A stop can also be required earlier if a support slips, a joint opens or anything becomes unsafe.

The load on a structure is a force. The invented table uses the mass added, in grams, as a convenient way to compare loading under the same gravity and arrangement. Grams are units of mass, not force units. Keep the mass unit clear and do not read a classroom mass figure as a safe capacity of a real bridge. You do not need a force calculation to make this controlled comparison.

Trace a load path: the route by which forces are passed through a structure to its supports. On a simple beam resting at both ends under a downward central load, bending involves compression near the top and tension near the bottom, away from complicated local effects. Compression tends to push or squash a member; tension tends to pull or stretch it. A photograph alone cannot tell you the force in every member of the real truss bridge, especially without knowing its loading and connections.

A clear specification also includes practical needs beyond one measurement. Is the surface wide enough for the intended display? Are joints tidy and secure? Can the model be handled appropriately, and is its material budget acceptable? A redesign that bends less but no longer provides the required surface has not automatically solved the whole design problem.

Try before checking: a beam has recorded deflection of eleven millimetres at an invented 400 gram test mass but does not snap. Does it pass our stated criterion? It fails the stiffness-related deflection requirement; absence of breakage is not enough. This is not evidence about the allowable mass for a different real prototype.

For an accessible alternative, work with labelled drawings, the supplied written data and verbal descriptions of shape changes. A teacher can provide large-print scales, pre-cut components or adapted grips for an approved practical activity. Analysing the fictional table shows conceptual understanding; it does not replace observation of actual making or safe testing.


Change geometry while keeping the comparison fair

A flat sheet and a folded sheet can behave differently even when they start with the same material quantity. Folds or a rolled section place material differently around the cross-section and can increase bending stiffness in a particular direction. That does not mean every fold improves every property. Creases, joints, orientation and the usable width still matter. Changing the amount or type of material at the same time makes a different comparison.

Close view of corrugated cardboard showing a wavy inner layer between liners
The separated layers and corrugation help you think about section geometry. This photograph is not a cross-section of the fictional paper prototypes or a measurement of their performance.

Triangulation uses triangular arrangements to resist some shape changes. Imagine ideal rigid bars joined by freely turning pins. A four-sided frame can rack into a sloping shape without changing the lengths of its bars. A diagonal can divide it into triangles and restrict that movement. Real card or paper members can bend, joints can slip and a flat frame can still move out of its plane. Do not turn the ideal model into a guarantee that any triangle is unbreakable.

Bracing adds support to resist an unwanted movement. A diagonal brace can change how a frame carries a load. A gusset is a plate or piece that helps connect members at a joint. Its shape, attachment and contact area can affect the joint, but adding a large gusset also adds material. If the question is whether joint design helps within a fixed budget, account for that material and hold the other conditions steady.

Science Buddies' paper-bridge demonstration supports discussion of shape and testing. With your teacher, identify a condition that must stay fixed and a result you would record. Do not copy a loading routine automatically: the teacher must approve the local setup and maximum test mass. The original provider's simple activity has a different stated age range; our Year 6 comparison adds explicit criteria, repeat trials, uncertainty and redesign reasoning.

For a fair shape comparison, define the variable you change, such as the cross-section fold pattern. Control the span, source material, material quantity, allowed tape, loading point and loading method. Use the same reference measurement and nominal stop rule. Record anything else that may differ, including construction accuracy or the direction of fibres. A changed support spacing can affect deflection even if a drawing looks similar.

For the fictional A/B comparison, both models use five grams of the same paper, the same allowance of tape and the same twenty-centimetre span. Their fold patterns differ. No claim is made that actual pupils built these models. At one selected trial, A has nine millimetres of deflection at 350 grams and eleven at 400 grams. B has nine at 500 grams and eleven at 550 grams. These are invented readings for reasoning practice, not recommended classroom loading targets.

Fictional model Paper mass Last recorded nominal pass First recorded criterion failure Deflection at that failure
A 5 g 350 g 400 g 11 mm
B 5 g 500 g 550 g 11 mm

The first recorded failures differ by 150 grams. The last recorded passes also differ by 150 grams in these particular trials. Do not call 400 grams A's safe load: that is its first recorded failure under the criterion. Nor do the two observations reveal the exact boundary between them. The result belongs to the stated measurement points, conditions and specimen.

ClickView's materials overview can help retrieve the difference between a material and its properties. In this A/B question the material source is controlled; we are changing the form. A later study of different materials is possible, but it needs its own question and protocol. Use the written definitions and examples if the external video is unavailable.

Plan before any approved practical work: use a low, contained tabletop setup with supports that cannot unexpectedly move. A teacher chooses suitable lightweight, secured test items, a local cap and a stop procedure. Keep faces and hands clear of a falling load, do not use people as loads and never test a real bridge. Stop for damage, slipping, excessive deformation or the teacher's instruction. No sharp tools, hot equipment, powered machinery or unsupervised construction are needed for the paper-based course.


Use repeat trials and evidence to justify a redesign

A single successful model can reflect a careful fold, a reading difference or a particular joint. Repeat trials help reveal variation. If a specimen has been damaged or permanently bent, unloading and loading it again is not equivalent to a fresh repeat. For a design comparison, prepare fresh specimens using the same stated construction method and record which specimen and trial each result belongs to.

The following original fictional trials use fifty-gram loading steps, the same nominal criterion and otherwise matched A/B conditions. These remain analysis data, not instructions to reach those masses. No learner or real prototype has been assessed by this table.

Design Trial one first failure Trial two first failure Trial three first failure Mean first failure Range
A 400 g 450 g 400 g About 416.7 g 50 g
B 550 g 550 g 600 g About 566.7 g 50 g

For A, add 400, 450 and 400 to get 1250, then divide by three. For B, the sum is 1700, divided by three. The difference between the exact means is 150 grams. The range is the highest minus the lowest reading, so each set has a range of fifty grams. A mean first-failure figure is still a summary of failures; averaging does not turn it into a safe working load.

With these fifty-gram steps, the corresponding last recorded passes are 350, 400 and 350 grams for A, and 500, 500 and 550 grams for B. Keep those data separate from first failure. The experiment has not located every specimen's exact limit. Three fictional repeats do not prove that B is always better for every build, every material direction or every kind of loading.

Measurement uncertainty matters near a boundary. If a reading described as ten millimetres has uncertainty of about one millimetre, the actual displacement could lie on either side of the nominal limit. Record the uncertainty and ask the teacher how the local test should handle the boundary. More confident wording is not a solution. Do not add further mass merely to make an uncertain result look decisive.

Material efficiency is also part of evaluation. For a simple declared classroom comparison, divide a selected trial's last recorded passing test mass by its paper mass. A has 350 divided by five, or seventy; B has 500 divided by five, or one hundred. An invented design C uses ten grams of paper, has a last recorded pass of 600 grams and a first failure of 650 grams. Its ratio is sixty. C's larger absolute passing mass does not make it the most efficient by this particular paper-mass ratio.

These ratios are not universal engineering scores. They omit tape, labour, cost, environmental impact, appearance and other requirements. If you include all material rather than paper alone, recalculate consistently. C does not belong to the controlled equal-material A/B test; it is an explicitly separate trade-off example. A product with a higher ratio could still fail the required surface-width or stability criterion.

Use observations to choose a redesign. If a joint opens before the rest of a frame deforms, investigate that joint rather than adding random material everywhere. A small gusset or a changed connection may be a hypothesis to test. If a beam bends too far while its joints remain intact, investigate section shape or orientation. If a support slides, fix and re-approve the test arrangement before attributing the result to the beam design.

For a fair redesign cycle, retain the old drawing, mark the one planned change, predict its effect, rebuild within the agreed budget and compare under the same protocol. Record an improvement, a drawback and an unresolved question. A stronger claim requires evidence: say that the recorded B specimens reached their first criterion failure at larger masses under these conditions, rather than that any folded shape is safe.

A complete test record includes the design version, specimen, span, material type and quantity, joint allowance, loading position, increments, unloaded reference, deflection readings, nominal criterion, actual stop reason, uncertainty and observation of any damage. Keep a sketch of the load path and the specific redesign reason. A photograph can support the record, but a photograph or online score alone does not demonstrate safe practical skill.

Teacher and learner review: for conceptual work, look for a fair comparison, accurate calculations, a clear distinction between pass and failure and a redesign justified by observations. Where actual practical competence is claimed, a teacher must observe the learner's making and test procedure in an approved environment. A written protocol or digital model cannot certify that competence. A learner using the paper alternative can still demonstrate careful design reasoning without pretending to have completed a physical test.


Interactive Tasks


Quiz: Test Your Knowledge

Which property concerns deformation under a stated load? (Stiffness) (!Only the colour of the material) (!The spelling of a product name) (!The number of people watching)



The nominal rule permits ten millimetres or less. What does an eleven millimetre reading mean? (The deflection criterion fails even without a break) (!The model passes because it is still one piece) (!The measurement can be ignored if the model looks attractive) (!Every real bridge must fail at the same mass)



What is a controlled variable in the equal-material A/B shape comparison? (The span between supports) (!A different paper mass for each design) (!A different loading point chosen after each result) (!A new stop rule selected to favour the winner)



What does compression tend to do to a member? (Push or squash it) (!Pull or stretch it) (!Automatically change its licence) (!Always eliminate every kind of bending)



What can an ideal diagonal brace help restrict? (Racking of a suitable pin-jointed frame) (!Every possible failure in every material) (!All movement regardless of joints and supports) (!Only changes in the photographs colour)



What is a gusset? (A connecting plate or piece at a joint) (!A universal safe test mass) (!A guarantee that the material cannot tear) (!The mean of any three numbers)



For trial one, what is A first recorded failure? (400 grams) (!350 grams) (!Its safe capacity for every future model) (!Any mass selected after removing the failed reading)



How much do the exact mean first-failure masses differ? (150 grams) (!50 grams) (!1250 grams) (!1700 grams)



Which design has the largest declared paper-efficiency ratio in the selected examples? (B with a ratio of one hundred) (!C because it uses the most paper) (!A because its first failure is called safe) (!All designs must have identical ratios)



What supports a claim of actual safe practical competence? (Direct teacher observation in an approved practical setting) (!A score from these fictional data alone) (!Watching a demonstration without making anything) (!A photograph with no procedure or supervision record)





Memory Game

Stiffness Resistance to deformation for a stated loading
Strength Ability to resist structural failure under loading
Stability Resistance to unwanted toppling sliding or support change
Compression A push or squashing action on a member
Tension A pull or stretching action on a member
Deflection A displacement measured from a reference position





Drag and Drop

Define criteria Choose the required behaviour and stop rules before testing
Control the comparison Hold span material budget and loading conditions steady
Record observations Keep specimen readings uncertainty and the actual stop reason
Compare the evidence Separate last pass first failure variation and other criteria
Justify a redesign Link a specific planned change to an observed problem





Crossword Puzzle

Stiffness What property concerns resistance to deformation under a stated load
Strength What property concerns resistance to failure under loading
Stability What property includes resisting unwanted toppling or sliding
Gusset What connecting plate can reinforce a joint
Bracing What adds support against unwanted movement
Deflection What displacement is measured from a reference position





LearningApps

Optional extra practice. Choose an appropriate activity with your teacher. If the external collection is unavailable, use the native activities and independent tasks in this course.


Cloze Text

Complete the explanation.
A checkable requirement is a design

. Resistance to deformation is

. Resistance to failure under loading is

. Resistance to unwanted toppling is

. A displacement from a reference is

. A pushing action is

. A pulling action is

. A connecting plate at a joint is a

. Supporting a frame against unwanted movement is

. A controlled comparison keeps the same

. Fresh specimens help investigate

. The difference between highest and lowest is the

. An average first failure is not automatically a safe

. The evidence should justify a specific

. Actual practical competence needs teacher

.



Open Tasks


Easy

  1. Distinguish three structural properties: Give an example of a stiff but unstable model and a flexible model that has not broken. Label stiffness strength and stability using the definitions.
  2. Mark a reference and deflection: Draw the unloaded and loaded positions of the same beam point. Show which change a ruler should measure and explain why table height is not the same measurement.
  3. Trace a simple load path: On an end-supported beam with a downward central load, describe how the load reaches the supports. Label the simple bending compression and tension regions without claiming to analyse every member of the photographed bridge.
  4. Check the nominal boundary: Apply the ten-millimetres-or-less rule to readings of nine ten and eleven. Explain why no break does not automatically mean the criterion passed.


Standard

  1. Plan an equal material comparison: Write an approved-test proposal stating the changed fold pattern and at least five conditions held fixed. Include the required surface width reference measurement local cap and stop procedure; do not carry it out without teacher approval.
  2. Read the fictional A and B trial: Distinguish last recorded pass from first failure in trial one. Calculate the two differences and explain what is not known between the measured loading steps.
  3. Summarise three fresh specimens: Calculate means and ranges for the two fictional designs. Explain why repeatedly loading a damaged specimen would not be an equivalent fresh repeat.
  4. Compare material efficiency: Calculate the declared paper-mass ratios for A B and C. State one omitted criterion and explain why C is not part of the equal-material A/B experiment.


Advanced

  1. Design a reasoned joint improvement: Use a fictional observation that a joint opens first. Propose one gusset or connection change within a stated budget, predict its effect and specify evidence that would support or challenge the prediction.
  2. Investigate measurement uncertainty: Discuss a nominal ten-millimetre reading with uncertainty of about one millimetre. Explain why a teacher-reviewed boundary policy is needed and why adding more mass is not a remedy for uncertainty.
  3. Create an accessible redesign portfolio: Make a before/after drawing and a structured evidence table using the fictional data or a separately approved observed practical. Label invented proposed and measured evidence correctly. Offer a spoken or large-print explanation.
  4. Transfer the reasoning to a display stand: Plan a new small display-stand enquiry with user requirements stability section geometry and joint criteria. Decide what can transfer from the bridge study and which conditions need fresh testing and approval.



Learning Check

  1. Check the criterion and force vocabulary: Interpret eleven millimetres at the fictional 400 gram test mass and explain the terms.
  2. Check controlled comparison and trial one: Compare A and B and identify what a fair shape study must hold fixed.
  3. Check repeat summaries: Calculate both mean first failures and ranges and state a limitation.
  4. Check the material trade off: Calculate the declared paper-efficiency ratios and evaluate C.
  5. Check a redesign and boundary plan: Propose an evidence-based response to an opening joint and an uncertain ten-millimetre reading.
  6. Check practical evidence and transfer: Describe what the final portfolio can demonstrate and what requires direct observation.


Worked checks and assessment guidance

  1. Eleven is greater than the nominal ten-millimetre limit, so the deflection criterion fails even if the beam remains unbroken. The example concerns stiffness as well as any later failure. Grams measure added mass, while a structural load is a force. Compression tends to squash and tension tends to stretch; a simple beam bending example does not determine every force in the photographed truss.
  2. A last passes at 350 grams and first fails at 400; B last passes at 500 and first fails at 550. The corresponding differences are each 150 grams. Control span paper source paper quantity tape allowance loading point loading method reference measurement and criterion. The first failure is not a safe load, and the exact threshold between readings is not measured.
  3. A totals 1250 grams over three trials, giving 1250 divided by three or about 416.7 grams. B totals 1700, giving about 566.7 grams. The exact mean difference is 150 grams. Each range is fifty grams. Those are fictional first-failure summaries from fresh specimens, not safe capacities or proof B always wins under all conditions.
  4. Using the selected trial last passes, A gives 350 divided by five or seventy, B gives 500 divided by five or one hundred, and C gives 600 divided by ten or sixty. B has the largest ratio by this stated measure. C has a larger absolute last passing mass but uses twice the paper. Tape cost labour environmental effects usable width stability and other criteria are not included, and C is a separate trade-off example.
  5. A joint-first problem can justify investigating a gusset or changed connection while keeping the comparison and total budget explicit. It is a hypothesis until tested. A nominal ten with about one millimetre uncertainty may lie on either side of the limit; record uncertainty and use the teacher-approved policy rather than forcing a result. Keep fresh specimens original drawings readings stop reasons and any drawbacks.
  6. The portfolio can demonstrate criteria controlled variables calculations source-informed structural ideas interpretation and a justified redesign. Real making or testing must be approved supervised and directly observed by a teacher where practical competence is claimed. Neither fictional results an online score a digital model nor a photograph alone certifies safe practical performance. A display stand needs its own user stability and loading criteria rather than an untested assumption that a bridge result transfers.


Learning evidence

Retain the user need and criteria, vocabulary and load-path sketch, original design and one specific redesign, equal-material controlled-test protocol, reference/deflection diagram, specimen-by-specimen fictional or actual labelled readings, last-pass/first-failure distinction, means ranges and declared efficiency calculation. Record uncertainty stop reasons trade-offs and one justified improvement. Conceptual evidence can be spoken written or drawn. For any claim of actual making/testing competence, attach the teacher's direct observation under the school's approved conditions; no such practical trial was performed or certified by this online lesson.


OER and Wikipedia

DfE England D&T programme, actual KS2 source inspected 15 November 2026. Criteria evaluation and strengthening/stiffening/reinforcing complex structures are whole-key-stage anchors. This exact Year 6 sequence and fictional test table are editorial.

Science Buddies: Paper Bridge Design Challenge, inspected as the primary provider of the embedded bridge video and basic shape comparison. Its original age range and testing directions are not substituted for a school's Year 6 risk assessment or this course's original criterion/repeat analysis. TeachEngineering: Polygons, Angles and Trusses, inspected for basic member compression/tension and geometry concepts; its advanced full lesson is not assigned as England Year 6 content.

West Fork Pigeon River Pratt Truss Bridge, Bethel, NC.jpg, Warren LeMay, CC BY-SA 4.0, unchanged bridge reference. Corrugated Cardboard.JPG, Richard Wheeler (Zephyris), CC BY-SA 3.0, unchanged section photograph. Exact fresh metadata preview bytes licences and native image identities checked; both previews visually inspected. Neither photograph is evidence of the fictional paper prototypes' performance.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CqYGVW2Eu6Y — Science Buddies: Paper Bridges STEM Activity. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=340MmuY_osY — ClickView: Materials And Their Properties. Exact original metadata player playability embedding permission embed pages and preview bytes checked; both previews visually inspected. Unmodified external embeds are supporting references, not copied transcripts endorsement or a new licence. Written definitions descriptions tables and paper tasks provide an alternative.

All A B C specimens masses deflections criteria repeat results means ratios and redesign scenarios here are original invented teaching examples. No actual build load test or professional safety assessment was performed. Author/source review and technical checks are not independent specialist certification.


Linked learning areas


aiMOOC Projects



Schulfach+




aiMOOCs



aiMOOC Projekte









MOOCwiki · Deutsch

Nach dem Lernen ist vor dem Lernen

Entdecke direkt den nächsten Lernkurs. Weitere Inhalte erscheinen, wenn Du weiter nach unten scrollst.

Zur MOOCwiki-Hauptseite

Mediathek

Suche verfeinern

Dein Lernplan bestimmt, was oben steht. Alle anderen Inhalte bleiben erreichbar. Seitenaufrufe beeinflussen die Auswahl nicht.

Inhalte werden geladen ...

Mediathek wird aus dem Wiki geladen ...