English:Year 7 investigation and evidence portfolio - Science Year 7
Introduction

Build a scientific report that another learner can inspect: a clear question, an appropriate enquiry plan, complete raw records, justified analysis and a conclusion that says exactly what the evidence supports. This capstone applies ideas from across Year 7 rather than repeating a list of laboratory rules.
All records are invented and supplied. You will plan and analyse on paper or with an accessible table/drawing tool, without heating water, handling chemicals or running an experiment. A completed report demonstrates reasoning; practical apparatus handling would require direct appropriate observation. Year 7 placement is editorial within England’s shared KS3 programme.
Design an answerable enquiry
Make the question answerable. 'Which cup is best?' leaves best undefined. A usable supplied-data question is: 'For otherwise identical cups with the same water mass and starting temperature, does the covered-lid arrangement retain a higher water temperature after ten minutes than the open arrangement in the same surroundings?' It names a response, comparison, timescale and relevant conditions. A prediction states an expected result before considering the data; it is not automatically the conclusion.
Choose an enquiry approach that fits the question. A controlled comparison deliberately changes a factor while keeping other relevant conditions consistent. An observation over time tracks changes without necessarily manipulating a cause. Classification groups objects by stated features, and pattern-seeking can reveal associations that are not necessarily causal. Scientific enquiries need not all follow one rigid universal sequence. The purpose is a defensible connection between question, method, data and reasoning.
Specify variables and apparatus for a paper plan. In the fictional cup enquiry, the changed factor is the lid arrangement, open or covered. The response is water temperature in degrees Celsius after a specified elapsed time. Controls include water mass, initial temperature, water material, cup shape/material, sensor position, room conditions and timing criteria. The full lid arrangement is the intervention; a result would not by itself isolate one lid material, thickness or evaporation pathway from every other feature.
The hypothetical apparatus list includes matching cups, a balance for equal water masses, a suitable temperature sensor and a clock/timer. Explain why each is needed and whether its range and resolution fit the intended values. Do not infer a sensor’s suitability from how many digits its display has. State the zero-time definition, how readings would be identified and what would be recorded if a planned reading were missed. This is planning, not an instruction to prepare hot liquid.
Three separate trials of each arrangement provide information about variation under the stated conditions. Repeatedly copying the same reading or reading an unmoving display three times is not equivalent to repeating the whole enquiry. Where appropriate, changing the order or alternating arrangements can reduce the chance that room drift is mistaken for an effect of the lid. Repeats and order choices need a reason, not merely the slogan 'make it fair'.
Record boundaries honestly. In the supplied model, each cup contains 150 g of water, begins at a displayed 65 °C and is in constant 20 °C surroundings. Cup geometry, sensor position and other named conditions are assumed matched. Those assumptions make the fictional comparison interpretable; they do not prove a real laboratory could hold every condition perfectly constant. Any real practical would need an appropriate authorised method, supervision and risk assessment. You are not asked to perform it here.
Keep raw records and choose suitable graphs
Keep raw records before summaries. The table below contains all six fictional trial records. The identifier distinguishes a trial from a condition label. Temperature columns include their unit and time in the heading, so a bare number does not have to carry an ambiguous meaning. Preserve the supplied values; do not change a value to make a graph smoother or repeat an expected pattern.
| Trial | Lid arrangement | Temperature at 0 min/°C | At 5 min/°C | At 10 min/°C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | Open | 65 | 54 | 44 |
| A2 | Open | 65 | 55 | 45 |
| A3 | Open | 65 | 56 | 46 |
| B1 | Covered | 65 | 59 | 53 |
| B2 | Covered | 65 | 60 | 54 |
| B3 | Covered | 65 | 61 | 55 |
For the open arrangement, the ten-minute values are 44, 45 and 46 °C: mean = 135 ÷ 3 = 45 °C and range = 46 − 44 = 2 °C. For covered cups, 53, 54 and 55 °C give mean 54 °C and range 2 °C. The mean final temperature difference is 9 °C. The mean drops from the shared 65 °C starting value are 20 °C open and 11 °C covered. These differences are temperature changes, not joules of energy.
The mean-time table is a derived summary. It is not six additional observations or a replacement for the raw trial table. At five minutes, open mean is 55 °C and covered mean is 60 °C. At zero, both means are 65 °C. Label the graph as a mean of three supplied trials per condition, rather than implying every individual trial exactly followed the mean curve.
| Elapsed time/min | Open mean temperature/°C | Covered mean temperature/°C |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 65 | 65 |
| 5 | 55 | 60 |
| 10 | 45 | 54 |
Choose a graph to answer a question. For temperature against elapsed time, put time horizontally and temperature vertically, use a clear linear scale, distinguish both series and give a legend. Plot all three mean points per condition. Lines can help show the pattern over a continuous variable, but sparse readings do not prove a particular exact curve between points. If the question instead compares only final means for two categories, a clearly labelled bar chart may be appropriate.
Use the same axis scale when comparing gradients. A carefully labelled shortened vertical scale can be useful for a line graph, but hiding its start or giving the two conditions different scales can mislead. For a bar-length comparison, a zero baseline normally preserves the meaning of bar lengths. Include units, condition labels, a descriptive title and the fact that values are supplied. Do not add an unmeasured fourth point simply because a smooth curve looks attractive.

The lower open-cup final mean is evidence about this response under these conditions. A graph makes that pattern easier to inspect; drawing one does not automatically prove a causal explanation or validate the method. Check the controls and records before interpreting the shape.
Evaluate variation, bias and unusual results
Distinguish variation, bias and uncertainty. Random influences can make repeated readings vary. A mean can reduce some effects of random variation when the readings are appropriate independent repeats, but it does not guarantee a true value. A systematic effect can shift readings consistently. For example, in a separate supplied calibration model, a sensor known to read 2 °C high would need a −2 °C correction: an indicated 45 °C corresponds to 43 °C in that model. This does not claim an actual sensor was calibrated or that a constant correction works outside a stated range.
Precision concerns how closely repeated results agree under specified conditions. Accuracy concerns closeness to an accepted/true value; in practice the true value is not directly known without qualification. A tightly clustered set can still be systematically shifted. Resolution describes a smallest distinguishable displayed step, not a guarantee of accuracy. Measurement uncertainty concerns the remaining doubt about a result and is not identical to a known error or the range of three repeats.
Repeatability refers here to agreement under the same specified observer, method and equipment conditions. Reproducibility explores agreement under stated changed conditions, such as another observer or laboratory. Define what changed rather than treating the labels as promises of truth. A finer display alone cannot fix incorrect timing, unsuitable sensor placement or an uncontrolled water mass.
Review an unusual result without erasing it. A separate fictional timing record contains 15, 16, 45 and 16 s. The mean of all four is 23 s and the range is 30 s. The 45 s reading is unusual relative to the others, but there is no documented reason to exclude it. It could reflect a recording problem, changed conditions or genuine variability. Flag it, inspect available method notes and propose a justified repeat rather than deleting it because it spoils a prediction.
As an explicitly labelled sensitivity calculation, removing 45 s would leave 47 ÷ 3 ≈ 15.67 s. That difference shows how influential the reading is; it does not establish that removal is legitimate. Keep the original record, both calculation labels and any documented reason for a later decision. If a real log proved the wrong timing interval was used, describe the deviation and analysis policy rather than silently rewriting history.
Recognise confounding. A flawed alternative comparison starts an open cup with 100 mL at 65 °C and a covered cup with 200 mL at 75 °C. Their later temperature difference cannot isolate the lid effect because starting temperature and amount changed as well. A beautifully drawn graph or a hundred repeats of this confounded comparison would not repair that design flaw. Correct the comparison plan, not just the appearance of the chart.
An improvement should target an identified weakness: define identical zero-time criteria to address timing variation, use an appropriate sensor-position support to reduce placement differences, or control mass to remove the amount confound. 'Be more careful' does not explain what will change or which uncertainty it addresses. Keep your recommendation proportional to the information supplied.
Write and review an auditable evidence portfolio
Separate record, interpretation and explanation. An observation statement from the model is: 'The supplied covered-cup final readings are 53, 54 and 55 °C.' An analysis statement is: 'Their mean is 54 °C, nine degrees above the open mean.' A cautious conclusion is that the covered arrangement retained a higher measured temperature in this specified ten-minute comparison. An explanation may propose reduced evaporation and other changes to energy transfer, but the temperature table alone does not measure the share of each mechanism.
The conclusion should answer the original question, quote relevant numbers and recognise limits. It does not establish a universal ranking of every lid, a precise energy saving in joules, a particular material’s safety or a probability that the explanation is certainly true. Distinguish a relationship supported by a controlled comparison from a pattern in unrelated observations where other causes may have changed.
Build a report another learner can audit. Give a concise question and prediction, plan/variables/apparatus rationale, labelled raw table, transparent calculations, suitable graph, conclusion, evaluation and source/provenance note. Identify invented supplied values as such and distinguish them from any future real observations. A method description should be specific enough to understand the comparison while avoiding a claim that a procedure was actually carried out.
| Portfolio section | What a reviewer should be able to find |
|---|---|
| Question and claim | A measurable question; prediction distinguished from outcome |
| Method and controls | Defined changed factor, response, apparatus and repeat strategy |
| Raw record and analysis | Units, all supplied trials, transparent means and graph choice |
| Conclusion and limits | Numerical evidence, inference and alternative explanations separated |
| Review and provenance | One justified improvement, change log and honest source/model labels |
A peer reviewer should check the numerical work, units, graph labels, controls and whether the conclusion overreaches. They can ask for a calculation or missing condition without attacking the author. Respond with a brief change log explaining the correction and retaining raw data. Peer review can improve a report; it does not guarantee there are no errors or replace specialist practical assessment.
Use the original Amoeba Sisters laboratory-safety overview to reflect on why apparatus planning, supervision and authorised procedures matter. The capstone itself is a supplied-data report, not permission to follow a video demonstration or proof of safe physical handling. No actual experiment is needed. Original: Amoeba Sisters, General Lab Safety. The written explanations and native tasks work without sound or the external player.
Transfer the framework. A fair comparison of plant growth would require a defined outcome and appropriate controls over factors such as species and light, while a sound-barrier enquiry needs source/receiver geometry and frequency controls. A classification task needs justified grouping criteria rather than automatically pretending there is a changed independent variable. Adapt the enquiry approach to the question; do not force every scientific task into a laboratory recipe.
Submit the complete report, corrected graph and short peer-review response together. Explain one remaining uncertainty and one targeted improvement. This portfolio demonstrates planning, numerical analysis, scientific interpretation and communication. It does not certify that you used apparatus safely, performed the experiment or independently confirmed a physical law.
Interactive Tasks
Quiz: Test Your Knowledge
What is deliberately changed in the specified controlled cup comparison? (The open or covered lid arrangement) (!The water mass and starting temperature together) (!The meaning of the Celsius unit) (!The reported outcome after seeing the data)
Which quantity is the main ten-minute response? (Water temperature in degrees Celsius after ten minutes) (!The author’s preferred answer) (!The observer’s name) (!The number of copied graph lines)
Which control directly addresses the amount-of-water confound? (Use the same stated water mass for each arrangement) (!Start the covered cup hotter) (!Move the two sensors to different depths) (!Use a larger covered cup without documenting it)
Why retain all six raw trial records? (They allow summaries and decisions to be inspected against the actual supplied values) (!Averages always make raw records irrelevant) (!Only values agreeing with a prediction are observations) (!A graph automatically proves that no recording error occurred)
What is the mean of the open final readings 44,45,46 °C? (45 °C) (!46 °C) (!135 °C) (!44.5 °C)
What is the difference between the covered and open final means? (9 °C) (!11 °C) (!20 °C) (!54 °C)
What is the range of the covered final readings 53,54,55 °C? (2 °C) (!54 °C) (!3 °C) (!162 °C)
What is the mean of the separate unedited timings 15,16,45,16 s? (23 s) (!16 s) (!15.67 s) (!45 s)
What does a finely divided display establish by itself? (Its display resolution rather than guaranteed measurement accuracy) (!That systematic error is impossible) (!That all uncontrolled variables are fixed) (!That its user performed a valid experiment)
What is a justified conclusion from the supplied controlled data? (The covered arrangement retained a higher measured temperature under these conditions) (!Every possible lid is always better in every context) (!The table alone measures each energy-transfer mechanism separately) (!Drawing a graph proves all causal claims are correct)
Memory Game
| Question | A defined enquiry that identifies what evidence is needed |
| Prediction | An expected outcome stated separately from the result |
| Independent variable | A factor deliberately changed in the controlled comparison |
| Dependent variable | The specified measured response |
| Control variable | A relevant condition kept consistent in the comparison |
| Inference | An interpretation that goes beyond merely reporting a reading |
Drag and Drop
| Raw trial table | The supplied record retained before summary calculations |
| Mean temperature series | A derived summary identified as such |
| Unusual timing without an exclusion reason | A flagged value retained for transparent review |
| Sensor known to read high in a stated model | A systematic effect needing an appropriate correction |
| Repeatedly hotter starting conditions for one group | A confound that repetition alone cannot repair |
Crossword Puzzle
| VARIABLE | What factor can change or be controlled in an enquiry? |
| CONTROL | What keeps a relevant condition consistent for the comparison? |
| REPEAT | What can provide another trial under stated conditions? |
| MEAN | What arithmetic summary divides the sum by the count? |
| GRAPH | What visual display needs clearly labelled axes or categories? |
| BIAS | What systematic influence can shift repeated readings? |
LearningApps
Optional extra practice. Choose an appropriate activity with your teacher. If the external collection is unavailable, use the native activities and independent tasks in this course.
Cloze Text
Open Tasks
Easy
- Define the enquiry: Rewrite which cup is best as a measurable question using response, time, comparison and conditions.
- Identify variables and tools: Name the changed factor, response, five controls and the reason for each proposed apparatus item in a paper plan.
- Check final means: Calculate both final means, ranges, mean drops and the final between-group difference, retaining units.
- Choose a graph: Explain a suitable graph for the time series and a different one for a final-category comparison; label every quantity.
Standard
- Plot the mean series: Plot all supplied mean points on common labelled axes, identify the raw trials behind them and avoid inventing observations between readings.
- Audit the timing anomaly: Calculate the unedited timing mean/range and the labelled leave-one-out sensitivity mean; explain why the latter is not permission to delete.
- Compare precision and bias: Explain why clustered readings may still be shifted, and apply the supplied positive-two-degree sensor correction to an indicated 45 °C.
- Repair a confounded comparison: Identify the amount/starting-temperature confounds in the flawed plan and propose changes that target those specific weaknesses.
Advanced
- Write a cautious conclusion: Separate the supplied observations, calculated pattern, supported comparison and possible mechanism; identify what the data do not establish.
- Peer-review a report: Review a fictional partner report for data integrity, arithmetic, axes, controls and overclaiming; give constructive evidence-based corrections.
- Transfer enquiry types: Adapt the framework to a plant-growth comparison, a sound-barrier question or classification, explaining why the enquiry method fits.
- Submit an auditable portfolio: Combine question, plan, complete records, graph, calculations, conclusion, limitations, improvement and review change log without claiming a physical practical.
Learning Check
- Plan and suitability: Define the question and justify variables, controls, tools and repeats.
- Transparent numerical summary: Calculate final means, ranges, drops and difference.
- Graph and inference: Choose a graph and state what it can support.
- Variation and calibration: Distinguish resolution, precision, accuracy and systematic correction.
- Anomaly and confounding: Evaluate both supplied flawed records without hiding data.
- Portfolio and review: Explain a supported report and one targeted improvement.
Worked checks and assessment guidance
- The question compares final water temperature after ten minutes for open versus covered arrangements under stated matching conditions. Lid arrangement is changed and temperature is the response. Control water mass/material, starting temperature, cup geometry/material, sensor position, ambient conditions and timing. A balance supports equal mass, a suitable sensor measures temperature and a timer defines intervals; resolution alone does not certify suitability. Separate full trials provide variation information. This is a paper plan, not a performed or authorised hot-liquid procedure.
- Open finals 44 + 45 + 46 = 135 give mean 45 °C and range 2 °C. Covered finals 53 + 54 + 55 = 162 give mean 54 °C and range 2 °C. Mean drops from 65 °C are 20 °C open and 11 °C covered; the final mean difference is 9 °C. Five-minute means are 55 °C and 60 °C. Keep all six trials and label derived mean rows. These are temperature quantities, not measured joules or shares of transfer mechanisms.
- Use elapsed minutes horizontally and temperature/°C vertically for both mean time series on common labelled axes with a legend. Identify three supplied trials per mean. A bar chart can instead compare final-condition means, with a meaningful zero baseline for bar lengths. Do not invent intermediate measurements or hide axis changes. The pattern supports higher covered-arrangement final temperature under stated conditions; a graph alone does not prove a causal mechanism or rescue an invalid method.
- Resolution is a distinguishable instrument step, precision is agreement of repeats under stated conditions, and accuracy concerns closeness to a true/accepted value with practical qualification. Uncertainty is remaining doubt, not automatically a repeat range or known error. A model sensor 2 °C high gives corrected 43 °C for an indicated 45 °C. Repetition can reduce some random effects but not automatically remove that bias; a correction itself needs a stated valid range and basis.
- The unedited timings 15 + 16 + 45 + 16 = 92 s give mean 23 s and range 45 − 15 = 30 s. Excluding 45 would give 47/3 ≈ 15.67 s only as a labelled sensitivity check; no documented cause supports deletion. Flag and investigate it while retaining the original. The alternative open 100 mL/65 °C versus covered 200 mL/75 °C plan changes amount and start temperature, so it cannot isolate the lid arrangement. More repeats or a neater chart do not repair that confound.
- An auditable report connects question/prediction, method/control rationale, complete raw data, calculations, graph, cautious conclusion and evaluation. A suitable improvement names the weakness and mechanism, such as fixed timing criteria for variable starts or equal mass for the amount confound. Separate observed supplied readings from analysis and inferred explanations. Peer review should test evidence and reasoning, retain raw data and log justified corrections; it is not a guarantee of truth or a substitute for directly observed practical handling.
Learning evidence
Keep the measurable question/prediction, justified paper plan, variables/apparatus/repeat rationale, all six supplied trials, transparent means/ranges/drops, labelled graph, anomaly/sensitivity decisions, bias/confound critique, cautious conclusion and documented peer-review response. Clearly label supplied fictional records and distinguish analysis/planning from a performed practical or apparatus-handling competence.
OER and Wikipedia
Original capstone explanations, fictional covered/open-cup records and repeat series, separate unusual-timing record, calibration/confound models, tasks and complete worked feedback. Commons references remain unchanged with their actual creator/licence/source records; neither image supplies measurements or proves a physical practical. The original Amoeba Sisters video was freshly checked for title, publisher, playability, embed and actual preview; the preview was inspected but the whole video was not watched, and no transcript/timestamp claim is made. No source worksheet, protected figure or physical procedure is copied.
Department for Education: KS3 Working scientifically, with editorial Year7 allocation. Institute of Physics: A language for measurements, consulted for validity, precision, accuracy, resolution, uncertainty and random/systematic distinctions, simplified for the intended learners without treating display steps or repeat ranges as universal uncertainty estimates. NIST TN1297: Appendix D1 Terminology, consulted for specified repeatability/reproducibility conditions rather than assuming the terms guarantee truth. Advanced uncertainty propagation is not required. Reviewed 13 November 2026.
Stoppuhr.jpg, Ulfbastel, Public domain. Unchanged original; caption and learning activities are original.
Heat conduction.png, Chcastan, Public domain. Unchanged original; caption and learning activities are original.
Linked learning areas
aiMOOC Projects
Schulfach+


aiMOOCs


aiMOOC Projekte


MOOCwiki · Deutsch
Nach dem Lernen ist vor dem Lernen
Entdecke direkt den nächsten Lernkurs. Weitere Inhalte erscheinen, wenn Du weiter nach unten scrollst.
Zur MOOCwiki-HauptseiteMediathek
Mediathek wird aus dem Wiki geladen ...
Keine passenden Inhalte gefunden. Bitte ändere Suche oder Filter.
NEWSLernweltNOAH fragen