English:Variation, natural selection and extinction - Science Year 9
Introduction

Distinguish continuous and categorical variation, choose an appropriate graph, and explain natural selection through inherited differences and unequal reproductive contribution. Compare two original environments and evaluate why adaptation does not guarantee protection from extinction.
Use the supplied records and fictional colour model. No personal trait survey, organism collection, breeding or predation experiment is required. Year 9 placement is editorial within England's shared KS3 programme.
Describe variation and choose a meaningful graph
Variation means differences among organisms. Separate variation within a species from differences between species. The historical opening illustration compares several finch species, so it is not a measured sample showing a frequency distribution within one finch population. An individual does not become another species merely by changing appearance.
Continuous variation can take values along a range. Seed length is measured in a unit such as millimetres, and intermediate lengths are possible. A measuring instrument records to a finite resolution, but that does not turn the underlying length into a fixed set of named biological categories.
The following twenty seed lengths are original supplied values in millimetres, recorded to the nearest tenth: 10.3, 10.8, 11.2, 11.7, 12.1, 12.2, 12.4, 12.7, 12.9, 13.1, 13.4, 13.6, 13.8, 14.2, 14.6, 15.1, 15.4, 15.8, 16.2, 17.6. They are not field measurements you performed.
Group them using clearly specified non-overlapping intervals. A value exactly 12.0 would go in the second interval under the stated boundary rule, not both the first and second.
| Seed-length interval/mm | Frequency |
|---|---|
| 10 to less than 12 | 4 |
| 12 to less than 14 | 9 |
| 14 to less than 16 | 5 |
| 16 to less than 18 | 2 |
The frequencies sum to 20. Draw a histogram with seed length on the horizontal numerical scale and frequency vertically. Each class is 2 mm wide, so count heights of 4, 9, 5 and 2 give areas proportional to frequency. The bars touch because adjacent intervals describe a continuous scale; their positions and widths have numerical meaning.
As an optional extension, frequency density is frequency divided by class width. For these equal classes the densities are 2, 4.5, 2.5 and 1 counts per millimetre. With unequal intervals, equal count heights would not generally make bar areas represent frequency correctly; choose and label the density scale.
Here d_f denotes frequency density, f frequency and w class width.
Discontinuous variation is recorded in distinct categories. Our later colour model defines two categories, light and dark, rather than measuring shade on a continuous colour scale. Use a bar chart with separate labelled categories and gaps; its bars do not represent adjacent numerical length intervals. A real colour measurement might instead be continuous, so choose the representation for the stated variable and question.
A distribution by itself does not establish the cause of variation. Genetic differences, environmental conditions and interactions can contribute. For example, different nutrients or water can affect plant growth. To attribute a length difference specifically to inherited information, you need appropriate evidence and comparisons, not simply a histogram with a wide spread.
Track inherited variants through selection
Natural selection connects inherited variation with reproductive contribution. Individuals in a population differ; some differences can be inherited. In a particular environment, variants may differ in their chances of surviving and leaving offspring. If inherited variants contribute unequally to the next generation, their proportions can change over generations.
The environment does not deliberately choose, and an individual does not acquire a needed inherited feature simply by trying. Variation must be available for selection to act on it. Mutations introduce sequence changes without aiming to solve an organism's future needs; selection is the environment-linked difference in success, not a purposeful mutation process.
Our original beetle-like population model starts with 100 individuals: 60 light and 40 dark. Colour is stipulated to be inherited in this fictional model. The supplied dark-background record gives survivors and a deliberately simplified reproduction rule: each survivor contributes two offspring with its colour. Real beetle reproduction and inheritance are more complex; these exact values are not a field experiment.
| Inherited colour category | Initial individuals | Supplied survivors | Model offspring |
|---|---|---|---|
| Light | 60 | 15 | 30 |
| Dark | 40 | 30 | 60 |
Light survival is 15/60=25%, while dark survival is 30/40=75%. There are 45 survivors in total, of whom 30 are dark. Dark frequency rises from 40/100=40% initially to 30/45=2/3, about 66.7%, among survivors. With the stated equal two-offspring contribution, the next generation has 30 light and 60 dark individuals, total 90, and the same two-thirds dark proportion.
The population total falls from 100 to 90 while dark frequency increases. An increasing proportion does not mean the total population must increase. The model does not say that light individuals turned dark, or that all light individuals died. It tracks changing contributions of inherited variants.
In evolutionary terms, fitness concerns reproductive contribution in a specified environment, not simply muscular strength or an organism's value. Here equal offspring per survivor makes the survival comparison translate directly into the reproduction comparison. If survivors differed in fertility, survival alone would not give the full reproductive outcome.
Use the original Natural History Museum explanation to follow inherited variation, environmental conditions and reproduction. Pause before a new generation is described and predict a change in proportions. Our numerical colour model is original and separate from the museum’s examples. Original: Natural History Museum, What is natural selection? | Natural History Museum. The written explanations and native tasks work without sound or the external player.
A real study would need evidence that the colour difference is inherited, consistent detection/sampling, relevant survival and offspring records, and controls for alternative explanations. Chance events can affect small populations; natural selection is not the only process that changes inherited-variant frequencies. Do not turn one supplied example into a universal forecast.
Compare environments, adaptation and extinction
An advantage depends on environmental conditions. Consider a separate original light-background scenario with the same initial 60 light and 40 dark individuals and the same simplified reproduction rule. Its supplied outcomes differ:
| Inherited colour category | Initial individuals | Supplied survivors | Model offspring |
|---|---|---|---|
| Light | 60 | 45 | 90 |
| Dark | 40 | 10 | 20 |
Now light survival is 45/60=75% and dark survival is 10/40=25%. The model offspring are 90 light and 20 dark, total 110. Dark frequency becomes 20/110=2/11, about 18.2%, compared with the initial 40%. A variant that increased in the dark-background example decreases in this one.
This contrast is an environmental comparison in a fictional model, not a claim that every darker organism is always advantaged or that every real trait follows a one-gene two-colour rule. A useful explanation identifies the inherited difference, relevant conditions, survival/reproduction evidence and the changed frequency.
A finch's beak can be advantageous for some available foods without being best for every possible food supply. The historical illustration helps you compare forms among species; it does not provide the survival counts or inherited-variation measurements needed to establish selection within one population. Its historical species labels are also not a substitute for current classification evidence.
Adaptation is not a promise of rescue. Environmental changes can remove suitable habitat, food or breeding opportunities. A population may lack variants that allow enough successful reproduction, or changes may occur too quickly for a population to persist. Evolution has no planned final destination and does not guarantee that every species will become perfectly fitted to every new condition.
Extinction means the loss of the entire species, not merely failure to find one individual or disappearance from one local site. A local population can vanish while the species survives elsewhere. Conversely, when the last members of a species die with no living population remaining, future natural selection cannot bring that species back from nothing.
Evidence of a decline needs a sampling method, dates, counts and attention to detectability. A lower count on one visit could reflect missed individuals, migration or a genuinely smaller population. Multiple sources of evidence are needed before making a strong global extinction claim. Fossils and historical records also have gaps, so absence in one record is not a complete census.
Keep a conclusion proportional to the evidence. In our dark-background model, inherited dark frequency increases under stated survival and reproduction conditions. In the light-background model it decreases. These are checked conditional outcomes, not a prediction for all habitats. The exercise requires paper calculations and interpretation only, not predation, breeding, collection or deliberate environmental change involving real organisms.
Interactive Tasks
Quiz: Test Your Knowledge
What type of variable is seed length in the supplied example? (A continuous measurement recorded to finite resolution) (!A named species category only) (!A guaranteed inherited genotype) (!A colour class with no numerical scale)
Which frequency belongs to twelve to less than fourteen millimetres in the supplied table? (Nine) (!Four) (!Five) (!Two)
Why do the equal-width length histogram bars touch? (Adjacent intervals represent a continuous numerical scale) (!Every seed has the same length) (!The graph proves all variation is genetic) (!Touching bars turn categories into genes)
What is appropriate for the model’s distinct light and dark colour categories? (Separate labelled bars with gaps) (!Treating the labels as adjacent length intervals) (!A histogram that assigns millimetres to colour names) (!A graph with no variable labels)
What is required for the supplied selection explanation across generations? (Inherited differences with unequal reproductive contribution under stated conditions) (!Individuals deliberately inventing needed inherited traits) (!Every mutation anticipating future needs) (!All individuals always producing identical numbers regardless of survival)
What is dark survival in the dark-background model? (Seventy-five percent) (!Twenty-five percent) (!Forty percent) (!Thirty percent)
What is the next-generation dark fraction in that model? (Two thirds) (!Two fifths) (!One quarter) (!Three tenths)
What happens to total population and dark frequency in the dark-background model? (The total falls while dark frequency rises) (!Both must rise together) (!Every light individual becomes dark) (!No offspring are produced)
What is the next-generation dark fraction in the separate light-background model? (Two elevenths) (!Two thirds) (!Three quarters) (!Exactly forty percent)
Which statement distinguishes extinction from local disappearance? (Extinction concerns the entire species rather than only one site) (!One missed observation proves global extinction) (!Every local disappearance means the species is gone worldwide) (!Adaptation always prevents extinction)
Memory Game
| Variation | Differences among organisms within or between groups |
| Continuous | A variable able to take intermediate values along a range |
| Histogram | A display whose numerical interval areas represent frequencies |
| Inheritance | Passing genetic information between generations |
| Natural selection | Environment-linked differences in contribution of inherited variants |
| Extinction | Loss of the entire species |
Drag and Drop
| Seed length is measured on a numerical scale | Use appropriately bounded continuous intervals |
| Light and dark are defined category labels | Use a labelled categorical bar chart |
| A model population changes variant proportions | Track inherited contributions across generations |
| A trait helps in one environment | Its advantage can change when conditions change |
| A species is absent from one surveyed site | Do not automatically infer global extinction |
Crossword Puzzle
| VARIATION | What term denotes differences among organisms? |
| HISTOGRAM | What graph represents frequencies across numerical intervals? |
| INHERITANCE | What passes genetic information between generations? |
| SELECTION | What process links inherited variants with different reproductive success? |
| ADAPTATION | What inherited feature can help in a particular environment? |
| EXTINCTION | What is the loss of the entire species called? |
LearningApps
Optional extra practice. Choose an appropriate activity with your teacher. If the external collection is unavailable, use the native activities and independent tasks in this course.
Cloze Text
Open Tasks
Easy
- Group the seed lengths: Place every supplied length in the stated interval and check the total frequency.
- Draw two graph types: Draw the equal-width length histogram and a separate bar chart for initial light/dark counts; label axes and units.
- Calculate dark-background survival: Calculate the survival fraction for each colour and total survivors using the supplied records.
- Describe the historical figure: Identify visible beak-form differences and explain why the illustration compares species rather than providing within-population frequency data.
Standard
- Track the next generation: Use the two-offspring rule to calculate both offspring counts, total and dark frequency without claiming individuals changed colour.
- Compare the second environment: Repeat the calculations for the light-background model and explain the opposite change in dark frequency.
- Check inherited versus environmental causes: Explain why a seed-length histogram alone cannot determine how much variation comes from genes or growing conditions.
- Distinguish disappearance and extinction: Write a cautious explanation of a missing local population, naming evidence needed before a global claim.
Advanced
- Use frequency density: Calculate density heights for the four length classes and explain why unequal class widths would need care.
- Evaluate a fitness claim: Critique an explanation based on strength alone or survival alone, separating reproductive contribution and the stipulated equal-offspring assumption.
- Audit a purposeful-mutation story: Rewrite a claim that organisms deliberately grow needed inherited features, including variation, environmental conditions, inheritance and chance.
- Design an evidence comparison: Specify sampling, inheritance and reproduction evidence needed to test a real selection hypothesis while identifying at least two alternative explanations; no real-organism experiment is required.
Learning Check
- Variation and graphs: Check interval counts and representations.
- Dark-background selection: Show the complete conditional account.
- Light-background comparison: Explain environmental dependence.
- Mechanism and limits: Explain inherited reproductive contribution.
- Image and evidence: Evaluate a claim based only on the finches illustration.
- Extinction and inference: Bound a conservation explanation.
Worked checks and assessment guidance
- The twenty lengths give frequencies four, nine, five and two in the successive two-millimetre classes. A histogram uses the numerical length axis and touching equal-width bars; heights can be these frequencies because widths are equal. Optional density heights are two, four and a half, two and a half and one per millimetre. The defined light/dark categories instead suit separate labelled bars with gaps.
- Light survival is fifteen of sixty, one quarter; dark survival is thirty of forty, three quarters. There are forty-five survivors, two thirds dark. The simplified equal-two-offspring rule gives thirty light and sixty dark, total ninety, with two-thirds dark frequency. Initial dark frequency was forty percent. The total population falls while dark proportion rises; no individual is said to change inherited colour.
- In the separate light-background model, forty-five of sixty light individuals and ten of forty dark individuals survive. Offspring are ninety light and twenty dark, total one hundred and ten, so dark fraction is two elevenths or about eighteen point two percent. The opposite direction of change demonstrates a conditional environmental advantage, not a universal hierarchy of better colours.
- A selection explanation requires variation that can be inherited and evidence of different contributions to later generations in relevant conditions. Mutation does not anticipate future needs, and individuals do not deliberately acquire needed inherited variants. The simple model stipulates inherited colour and equal offspring per survivor; real inheritance, fertility, chance and other evolutionary processes can alter the outcome.
- The historical image compares forms among different finch species and supplies no survival counts, genetic measurements or within-population histogram. It can prompt questions about food-related beak function, but cannot alone establish a specific selection mechanism or prove that one individual developed a needed beak. Distinguish observed form, model explanation and the additional evidence required.
- Adaptation does not guarantee rescue when environments change or reproduction becomes insufficient. Global extinction concerns the entire species; local absence can have other causes and the species may persist elsewhere. A claim needs suitable sampling, dates, detectability and wider evidence. Our two original environments establish their own conditional frequency calculations, not a universal future forecast or a performed practical.
Learning evidence
Retain an independently checked frequency table and correctly labelled histogram/bar chart, complete survival and offspring accounts for both model environments, an inheritance-and-reproduction explanation and a cautious extinction inference. State what the historic image does not measure and what evidence a real study would need. Separate supplied calculations from practical work and population frequency change from individual intention.
OER and Wikipedia
Original seed-length records, interval grouping, two environmental population models, learning tasks and worked feedback. John Gould’s historical public-domain illustration and the actual original Natural History Museum video preview were visually inspected; current media identities/rights and bytes checked, not a full-film transcript. The illustration compares species, not the original within-population datasets. No source figures, measured research datasets or protected exercises copied.
Natural History Museum: What is natural selection?, Emily Osterloff, environment-linked inheritance/reproduction, limited adaptation and finch-evidence distinctions consulted. Natural History Museum: Evolution education curriculum map, KS3 variation, graphing and extinction context consulted. OpenStax Biology 2e: Population evolution, inherited-variant frequencies and the distinction between selection and other evolutionary processes consulted; no Hardy–Weinberg calculation is required. DfE Science programme, editorial Year 9 allocation within shared KS3. Reviewed 13 November 2026.
Darwin's finches by Gould.jpg, John Gould (14.Sep.1804 - 3.Feb.1881), Public domain. Unchanged original; caption and learning activities are original.
Linked learning areas
aiMOOC Projects
Schulfach+


aiMOOCs


aiMOOC Projekte


MOOCwiki · Deutsch
Nach dem Lernen ist vor dem Lernen
Entdecke direkt den nächsten Lernkurs. Weitere Inhalte erscheinen, wenn Du weiter nach unten scrollst.
Zur MOOCwiki-HauptseiteMediathek
Mediathek wird aus dem Wiki geladen ...
Keine passenden Inhalte gefunden. Bitte ändere Suche oder Filter.
NEWSLernweltNOAH fragen